# 10b5-1 Plans in an Acquisition Scenario

URL: https://vestedgrant.com/equity-comp/10b5-1-acquisition-scenarios
Updated 2026-11-21 · Facts checked 2026-11-21 · Tax year 2026

What happens to a 10b5-1 plan when the company is acquired, why adopting or changing a plan during deal talks is risky, and how the one-plan rule and cooling-off periods apply at the acquirer.

## Answer

A 10b5-1 plan adopted before a person learned of acquisition talks keeps its affirmative defense for trades made on schedule during those talks, as long as the person does not change or game it. Adopting or changing a plan while aware of the talks forfeits the defense. After a stock-for-stock deal closes, a new plan in acquirer shares needs a fresh cooling-off: 90 to 120 days for officers and directors in 2026.

## Key takeaways

- Trades under a plan adopted before the insider was aware of deal talks keep the Rule 10b5-1 defense, because the rule looks at awareness when the plan was adopted.
- A change to a plan's amount, price or timing during deal talks is a new plan adopted while aware of material nonpublic information, so the defense is lost for the new terms.
- Rule 10b5-1 requires the insider to act in good faith with respect to the plan throughout, so cancelling trades or influencing disclosure timing around a deal can undermine the defense.
- A plan in target shares cannot sell acquirer shares after closing; a plan in acquirer stock is a new plan with a 90-to-120-day cooling-off for officers and directors, or 30 days for others.

Consider an executive with a 10b5-1 plan running at her company. Months after she adopted it, the board begins discussing a sale of the company, and the deal is later signed at a premium to the market price. The plan has been executing on schedule: three trades completed before signing and one more scheduled for the day after the announcement. She now faces several questions. Was the plan's continued operation during the talks consistent with the good-faith condition? Does the post-announcement trade keep the affirmative defense? What happens to the plan after closing?

Acquisitions produce some of the hardest 10b5-1 questions, because deal talks generate material nonpublic information (MNPI) and because trade timing around a deal can look opportunistic even when it is not. This article follows a plan through four stages of a deal: talks before announcement, the announcement itself, the period before closing, and after closing.

## Does a 10b5-1 plan keep working during deal talks?

A 10b5-1 plan adopted before the insider became aware of deal talks keeps working during them. The Rule 10b5-1(c) defense asks whether the plan was adopted, in good faith, before the person became aware of the information. If it was, trades that occur under the plan's original terms are not "on the basis of" the later-acquired information, even though the insider is aware of it when the trades occur. That is the central purpose of a 10b5-1 plan.

Whether early talks are themselves MNPI depends on the facts, such as how likely a deal is and how large it would be. Once talks are serious enough to be material to investors, they are MNPI for everyone inside the circle of knowledge.

The defense also depends on how the insider behaves after adoption. The amended rule requires that the person "has acted in good faith with respect to" the plan. An insider who leaves the plan alone during talks is in the strongest position.

## What should an insider avoid during deal talks?

Three actions during nonpublic deal talks put the defense at risk.

- **Adopting a new plan.** A plan adopted while aware of material deal talks fails the basic condition of the defense. For officers and directors, the required certification that they hold no MNPI would also be untrue.
- **Modifying an existing plan.** Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)(iv) treats any change to the amount, price or timing of planned trades as a termination and a new adoption. A change made during the talks is a new plan adopted while aware of MNPI.
- **Cancelling trades or terminating the plan.** Not selling is not itself a trade, but the SEC's 2022 release describes selective cancellation of planned trades on the basis of MNPI as one of the abuses the amendments targeted. A termination during talks undermines the good-faith picture for any replacement plan and draws attention when it appears in the company's Item 408(a) disclosure for the quarter.

When an insider has a reason unrelated to the deal for changing a plan, such as a divorce or a new tax bill, the reason and its timing matter. Counsel typically documents that reason in writing at the time.

## What happens to trades scheduled around the announcement?

A trade scheduled for the day of, or the day after, a deal announcement executes under the plan's terms like any other trade. If the plan set the date and amount, or a formula for them, before the insider knew of the deal, the price the trade receives after the announcement does not change the analysis. The insider did not choose the timing; the plan did.

The trade may still draw attention. "Executive sold into the deal premium under a plan adopted months earlier" is an easy headline, and the trade appears on a Form 4 with the 10b5-1 checkbox marked. The company's investor relations team may need to explain the plan's adoption date, which is already in the Item 408(a) disclosure if the executive is a director or officer.

Some insider trading policies and plan documents give the company the right to suspend plan trading for legal or contractual reasons, for example when a merger agreement restricts trading. That is a company or plan-document choice, not a requirement of Rule 10b5-1. Whether a suspension applies to a given plan depends on the plan's terms.

## Does the plan keep trading between signing and closing?

Between announcement and closing, the deal itself is public, so trades under an existing plan do not raise a deal-related MNPI question. The plan keeps executing under its terms unless the plan document or the merger agreement says otherwise.

Other MNPI can arise during this period: the status of regulatory review, financing problems, integration plans or a renegotiated price. A plan adopted before the insider knew of those matters keeps its defense for them as well, on the same principle. A plan adopted or changed after the insider learned of them does not.

The deal terms also decide what happens to the equity the plan was selling. Merger agreements commonly specify whether vested shares are converted into cash, acquirer stock or a mix, and whether unvested awards are cashed out, accelerated or assumed by the acquirer. A plan that sells target shares can only sell shares that still exist and are in the account. Reviewing both the plan document and the merger agreement shows whether trades scheduled after closing can execute at all.

## What happens to the plan after closing?

After closing, the result depends on the form of consideration.

| Deal type | What happens to target shares | Effect on an existing 10b5-1 plan |
|---|---|---|
| All-cash acquisition | Shares are cancelled for cash at closing | Nothing left to sell; the plan is moot |
| Stock-for-stock merger | Shares convert into acquirer shares | A plan written for target stock does not automatically cover acquirer stock |
| Mixed or rollover consideration | Part cash, part acquirer equity or rollover units | Each piece follows its own terms; acquirer stock needs its own plan |

A plan that names the target company's common stock ends in practice when that stock is cancelled. Few plans are drafted to carry over to acquirer shares, and rewriting a plan to cover acquirer stock is a change to the plan's terms, which makes it a new plan.

## How do the one-plan rule and cooling-off apply at the acquirer?

A plan to sell acquirer shares after closing is a new plan for the acquirer's securities. The one-plan limit in Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)(ii)(D) applies to plans for a given issuer's securities, so a terminated or moot plan for target stock does not block a plan for acquirer stock.

The new plan carries the full current conditions. If the person is a director or officer of the acquirer, the cooling-off period for 2026 is the later of 90 days or two business days after the acquirer's 10-Q or 10-K for the quarter of adoption, capped at 120 days, and the certification is required. Anyone else waits 30 days. An executive who wants continuous selling capacity across a closing will have a gap while the new cooling-off runs.

The new plan must also be adopted when the person is not aware of MNPI about the acquirer, which can be harder in the months right after a deal, when integration plans and synergy targets may not yet be public. If the person becomes a director or officer of the acquirer, the acquirer's own insider trading policy, windows and pre-clearance rules apply from that point.

## What if the deal talks end without an announcement?

If talks end without any announcement, existing plans continue under their terms. Nothing needs to be changed.

Adopting a new plan is harder. The insider knows something the market does not: that a deal was explored and dropped. Whether that knowledge is still material, or has become stale, is a question of fact. There is no fixed waiting period in the rule, and the answer depends on how advanced the talks were and whether the information still matters to investors. Counsel's view on when the information stopped being material, recorded at the time, is part of the good-faith record for the new plan.

## When does deal timing put the 10b5-1 defense at risk?

The 10b5-1 defense is strong but not absolute. In an acquisition the main weak points are:

- **Adoption during talks.** A plan adopted while aware of material talks lacks the defense for all of its trades.
- **Modification during talks.** The changed plan is a new plan adopted while aware of MNPI.
- **Termination or cancellation around the deal.** Trades completed before termination keep the defense if the plan was valid, but the pattern can be cited as evidence of bad faith, and any replacement plan starts a new cooling-off.
- **Influencing disclosure.** The SEC's release states that an insider who, while aware of MNPI, induces the company to time a disclosure to benefit plan trades is not acting in good faith, even if the plan was properly adopted.
- **Adoption just before talks begin.** A plan adopted shortly before talks start may draw questions about whether the deal was foreseeable. A contemporaneous record of what the insider knew at adoption is the main protection.

## Questions people ask next

### What happens to my 10b5-1 plan when target shares stop trading at closing?

A 10b5-1 plan that sells target company shares has nothing left to sell once those shares are cancelled or converted at closing. Plan documents often say what happens on a change of control; if they do not, the plan stops working in practice. Selling acquirer shares received in a stock deal needs a new plan, with a new cooling-off period.

### Can I change my 10b5-1 plan to account for a pending deal?

Changing the amount, price or timing of a 10b5-1 plan is a termination and a new adoption under Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)(iv). If the change happens while the insider is aware of nonpublic deal talks, the new plan is adopted while aware of material nonpublic information and has no affirmative defense. After the deal is announced the analysis turns on any other nonpublic information.

### Do acquirer executives face the same 10b5-1 limits during a deal?

Executives at the acquiring company who know about a nonpublic deal are in the same position as target executives with respect to the acquirer's stock, if the deal is material to the acquirer. Existing plans adopted before they knew can keep running. A new or changed plan adopted while aware of the deal does not get the Rule 10b5-1 defense.

### Does the 10b5-1 certification cover merger talks?

The 10b5-1 certification required of officers and directors covers any material nonpublic information about the company or its securities, so it is not limited to financial results. An officer who knows of material, nonpublic merger talks cannot truthfully certify a lack of such information, and a plan adopted on that basis lacks the affirmative defense.

### Can a company blackout stop trades under an existing 10b5-1 plan during a deal?

Rule 10b5-1 does not require plan trades to stop for a company blackout during a deal. Some plan documents let the company suspend trading for legal or contractual reasons, such as a lock-up or a deal restriction. Whether a suspension applies depends on the plan's own terms, which are set when the plan is adopted.

## Sources

1. [17 CFR 240.10b5-1 (eCFR)](https://www.ecfr.gov/api/renderer/v1/content/enhanced/current/title-17?part=240&section=240.10b5-1)
   > no purchases or sales occur until expiration of a cooling-off period consisting of the later of: (i) Ninety days after the adoption of the contract, instruction, or plan or
2. [SEC Release 33-11138, good faith and disclosure timing](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/12/29/2022-27675/insider-trading-arrangements-and-related-disclosures)
   > a corporate insider would not be operating a Rule 10b5-1 plan in good faith if the corporate insider, while aware of material nonpublic information, directly or indirectly induces the issuer to publicly disclose that information
3. [17 CFR 229.408(a), quarterly disclosure of adoptions and terminations](https://www.ecfr.gov/api/renderer/v1/content/enhanced/current/title-17?part=229&section=229.408)
   > Disclose whether, during the registrant's last fiscal quarter (the registrant's fourth fiscal quarter in the case of an annual report), any director or officer
