# Good-Faith Adoption of a 10b5-1 Plan: The SEC's New Certification Requirement

URL: https://vestedgrant.com/equity-comp/10b5-1-good-faith-adoption
Updated 2026-11-21 · Facts checked 2026-11-21 · Tax year 2026

Since February 27, 2023, officers and directors must certify in the 10b5-1 plan itself that they hold no material nonpublic information and are adopting it in good faith. Here is what the certification means and the review that usually comes before it.

## Answer

Under Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)(ii)(C), in force since February 27, 2023, a director or officer adopting a 10b5-1 plan must include a representation in the plan certifying that, on the adoption date, the person is not aware of material nonpublic information about the company or its securities and is adopting the plan in good faith, not as a scheme to evade insider trading rules. Other employees do not certify but must still adopt in good faith.

## Key takeaways

- Directors and officers must put the no-MNPI and good-faith certification inside the plan document; it is not filed with the SEC.
- The SEC stated that the certification does not create an independent basis of liability, but a false one removes the affirmative defense and leaves a contradictory signed record.
- Information is material under the case law the SEC relies on if there is a substantial likelihood a reasonable investor would view it as significantly altering the total mix of information.
- Good faith now runs for the life of the plan: the person must have acted in good faith with respect to the plan, not only when adopting it.
- The SEC dropped a proposed rule to keep the certification for ten years, noting that the insider carries the burden of proving the defense anyway.

Before 2023, adopting a 10b5-1 plan in good faith and without material nonpublic information (MNPI) was already a condition of the affirmative defense, but nothing required the insider to say so in writing. Executives signed plan documents, the legal team confirmed the timing, and the record often consisted of little more than the plan itself. If an enforcement action later alleged that the plan was adopted while the insider held MNPI, the defense turned on whatever evidence existed.

The amendments that took effect on February 27, 2023 added Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)(ii)(C). A director or officer must now include a representation in the plan certifying that, on the date of adoption:

1. The individual is not aware of any material nonpublic information about the security or the issuer; and
2. The individual is adopting the plan in good faith and not as part of a plan or scheme to evade the prohibitions of the rule.

This article explains what the certification means, the review that usually comes before it, and the timing questions that follow.

## What does “not aware of material nonpublic information” mean?

The certification uses the same awareness test as the rest of Rule 10b5-1. Information is "material," under the Supreme Court case law the SEC relies on, if there is a substantial likelihood that a reasonable investor would view its disclosure as significantly altering the total mix of available information. It is "nonpublic" until it has been disclosed to the market.

For a director or officer, categories that often contain MNPI include:

- Financial results for a quarter that has not been reported
- Unannounced acquisitions, sales or financings
- Major customer, product or partnership developments
- Government investigations or regulatory actions
- Leadership changes not yet announced
- Significant litigation developments
- Material cybersecurity incidents

The test is awareness, not use. An executive who has seen preliminary numbers that differ materially from guidance is aware of them, even without having studied them closely.

## What do “good faith” and “not a scheme to evade” add?

The good-faith part of the certification covers purpose. A plan adopted to diversify, raise cash, pay taxes or fund gifts is consistent with good faith. A plan designed to look pre-set while really capturing a known event is not. A plan built to sell heavily in the two days after an earnings release the insider already knows will be weak is the classic scheme to evade.

Good faith also continues after adoption. The amended rule requires that the person "has acted in good faith with respect to" the plan. The SEC gave an example in its release: an insider who, while aware of MNPI, induces the company to time a disclosure so that plan trades become more profitable is not acting in good faith, even if the plan was properly adopted. Changing or cancelling trades because of later-learned information raises the same issue.

## What happens if the certification turns out to be false?

The SEC said in its 2022 release that the certification does not create an independent basis of liability for insider trading. The consequences of a false certification run through the affirmative defense and the evidence:

- **The defense fails.** A plan adopted while the officer was aware of MNPI does not meet the conditions of Rule 10b5-1(c), so trades under it are judged under ordinary insider trading law.
- **The record is worse.** A signed statement that the officer had no MNPI, made on a day the officer did, is strong evidence against the officer in an SEC action or a private suit.
- **The disclosure is public.** For officers and directors, the adoption date is already in the company's Item 408(a) disclosure, so investors and plaintiffs can match it against later events.

The insider also carries the burden. The SEC dropped a proposed instruction to keep the certification for ten years, explaining that the person who wants to rely on the defense must prove its conditions anyway and so already has reason to keep accurate records.

## What review usually comes before signing?

Companies commonly run a structured review with the legal team before an officer adopts a plan. A typical sequence:

1. **Window check.** The legal team confirms that the company's trading window is open under its insider trading policy and that no special blackout is in effect.
2. **MNPI interview.** The officer and counsel walk through each category: results, transactions, customers and products, regulatory matters, personnel, litigation and security incidents. Counsel records the answers.
3. **Company-side check.** Counsel compares the officer's answers with what the legal team knows about pending matters across the company.
4. **Signature.** The officer signs the plan, with the certification language tracking Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)(ii)(C).
5. **Records.** The company and the officer keep the signed plan and the review notes, and the legal team logs the adoption for the next Item 408(a) disclosure.

Some companies also inform a board committee when senior officers adopt large plans. None of these steps is required by the rule; together they create the contemporaneous record that supports the certification.

## Which situations are clear and which are gray?

Some situations are easy to classify; others call for judgment.

| Situation | Usual treatment |
|---|---|
| Board-approved acquisition not yet announced | MNPI |
| Preliminary results showing a large miss against guidance | MNPI |
| Notice of an imminent regulatory rejection of a key product | MNPI |
| General optimism about the company's prospects | Not MNPI |
| Widely reported industry trends | Not MNPI |
| Rough early numbers that may not hold | Gray area |
| Early acquisition talks that may go nowhere | Gray area |
| An undisclosed health issue of a senior executive | Gray area |

Gray areas are where counsel's analysis matters most. A cautious approach treats them as MNPI and delays adoption until the information is disclosed or no longer matters.

## How do directors handle the certification?

Directors receive information continuously through board and committee meetings, so the certification can be harder for them than for operating officers. The certification does not require a director to know nothing nonpublic about the company; it requires that the director not be aware of information that is both material and nonpublic.

In practice, directors commonly adopt plans shortly after the company has released its quarterly results, when the board's most recent financial information has just become public. After a meeting that dealt with a transaction or a crisis, the information may stay material until the company announces it, and adoption waits until then. The legal team's view, recorded at the time, is part of the director's good-faith record.

## When is the cleanest time to adopt a plan?

The cleanest time to adopt is usually soon after the company files its 10-Q or 10-K and releases earnings, when the quarter's results are public and the next quarter's results are not yet known. Company insider trading policies often define an open trading window that starts after the earnings release and closes some weeks before the next quarter ends; adopting within that window and early in it reduces the chance of holding undisclosed results.

The adoption date also starts the cooling-off clock. For a director or officer in 2026, the first trade cannot occur until the later of 90 days after adoption or two business days after the 10-Q or 10-K for the quarter of adoption, and never more than 120 days after adoption. For other employees the wait is 30 days. Adoption early in a quarter shortly after an earnings release means the 90-day branch usually controls.

## What are the practical points to keep in mind?

Several practical points follow from the rule and the SEC's release:

- **Do the interview properly.** A cursory review weakens the certification later.
- **Write down judgment calls.** If an officer knows something that counsel concludes is not material, a note of the reasoning made at the time carries weight later.
- **Avoid adoption just before announcements.** If results, a deal or a major operational event is about to be disclosed, waiting until after the disclosure is the safer sequence.
- **Leave the plan alone.** Each change to amount, price or timing is a new adoption, with a new certification and a new cooling-off period, and repeated changes draw attention in Item 408(a) disclosures.

## Questions people ask next

### Do employees who are not officers have to sign the 10b5-1 certification?

The written 10b5-1 certification in Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)(ii)(C) applies only to directors and officers as defined in SEC Rule 16a-1(f). Other employees do not sign it. They still need to adopt the plan before becoming aware of material nonpublic information, in good faith, and keep acting in good faith while it runs, to rely on the affirmative defense.

### Can the general counsel sign the 10b5-1 certification for an officer?

The 10b5-1 certification is a representation by the individual director or officer about that person's own knowledge and intent on the adoption date. It is made in the plan the officer adopts. The company's lawyers can run the review that supports it, but the representation is the officer's own and cannot be made for the officer by someone else.

### What if I learn material nonpublic information after certifying but before the cooling-off ends?

The 10b5-1 certification speaks to the adoption date. Information learned afterward does not make it untrue, and trades under the unchanged plan can keep the affirmative defense. What the officer must not do is change the plan's amount, price or timing, or cancel trades, because of the new information, since that is a new adoption or a lapse in good faith.

### Is a verbal assurance enough for the 10b5-1 certification?

A verbal assurance does not satisfy the 10b5-1 certification. The rule requires the director or officer to include the representation in the plan itself. A separate email or a conversation with counsel can support the record, but the certification has to be part of the written plan document.

### Does a pre-2023 10b5-1 plan need a certification?

A 10b5-1 plan adopted before February 27, 2023 keeps the affirmative defense under the conditions that applied when it was adopted, so it does not need a certification. If the plan is changed in amount, price or timing after that date, the change creates a new plan, and a director or officer must then include the certification.

## Sources

1. [17 CFR 240.10b5-1 (eCFR)](https://www.ecfr.gov/api/renderer/v1/content/enhanced/current/title-17?part=240&section=240.10b5-1)
   > no purchases or sales occur until expiration of a cooling-off period consisting of the later of: (i) Ninety days after the adoption of the contract, instruction, or plan or
2. [SEC Release 33-11138, certification and liability](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/12/29/2022-27675/insider-trading-arrangements-and-related-disclosures)
   > We think it is sufficiently clear that the certification would not create an independent basis of liability for insider trading
