# Multiple 10b5-1 Plans: The Single-Plan-at-a-Time Rule and Its Exceptions

URL: https://vestedgrant.com/equity-comp/10b5-1-single-plan-rule
Updated 2026-11-21 · Facts checked 2026-11-21 · Tax year 2026

Since February 27, 2023, a person other than the issuer may generally rely on only one open-market 10b5-1 plan for a company's securities, of any class. Here are the three exceptions, the separate single-trade limit and how to design around the rule.

## Answer

Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)(ii)(D) denies the affirmative defense to a person who holds more than one open-market 10b5-1 plan for any class of the same company's securities, with three exceptions: contracts with several brokers treated as one plan, one later-commencing plan that cannot trade until the first finishes, and a plan that only sells to cover tax withholding at vesting. A separate limit allows one single-trade plan per 12 months.

## Key takeaways

- The one-plan limit covers open-market plans for any class of the company's securities; the SEC removed the proposed same-class wording in the final 2022 rule.
- Separate contracts with different brokers count as a single plan if together they meet the rule's conditions, and a change to one of them is a change to the whole plan.
- A second, later-commencing plan is allowed if it cannot trade until the first plan's trades are complete or expired and its first trade falls outside the effective cooling-off period.
- A plan limited to selling shares for tax withholding at vesting does not count, but the SEC declined to extend that carve-out to option exercises.
- Transactions that are not on the open market, such as employee benefit plan, ESOP or dividend reinvestment purchases, fall outside the one-plan limit.

Consider an executive who wants to sell a slice of each quarterly RSU vest while also planning a one-off sale ahead of a charitable gift. Before 2023, she could have set up two plans with different triggers, and the SEC's 2022 release describes insiders adopting multiple overlapping plans. Since the amendments took effect on February 27, 2023, Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)(ii)(D) denies the affirmative defense to a person who holds more than one open-market plan for the company's securities, except in three defined cases. Getting this wrong can cost the defense for every trade involved.

This article covers what the rule prohibits, its exceptions, the separate single-trade limit and how to fit several goals into one plan.

## What does the one-plan rule prohibit?

The one-plan rule makes the affirmative defense available only if the person, other than the issuer, "has no outstanding (and does not subsequently enter into any additional)" plan that would qualify for the defense "for purchases or sales of the issuer's securities on the open market." Holding two qualifying open-market plans at once, outside the exceptions, removes the defense.

Three points about scope:

- **Any class of securities.** The SEC's proposal would have applied the limit per class of securities. The final rule removed that wording, so the limit covers plans for any class of the company's securities. Separate plans for common stock and for another class of the same company are two plans.
- **Open-market trades only.** The SEC said the limit does not apply to plans that do not involve open-market transactions, such as employee benefit plans, ESOPs or dividend reinvestment plans, where purchases come directly from the company.
- **Per company.** The rule refers to "the issuer's securities," so a director who sits on two public boards can have one plan for each company's stock.

The SEC adopted the limit because insiders had used overlapping plans to keep options open and then cancel the less favorable plan after learning material nonpublic information (MNPI).

## What are the three exceptions?

The rule lists three exceptions:

| Exception | What it allows | Key condition |
|---|---|---|
| Multiple brokers | Separate contracts with different brokers treated as one plan | Together they meet all the rule's conditions; a change to any contract changes the whole plan |
| Later-commencing plan | One additional plan adopted while the first is in force | It cannot trade until all trades under the first plan are complete or expired, and its first trade is outside the effective cooling-off period |
| Sell-to-cover | A plan that only sells shares for tax withholding at vesting | Limited to withholding on the vesting of an award such as restricted stock; the insider has no control over timing |

Single-trade plans are not an exception to the one-plan rule. They are subject to a separate limit, described below, on top of the one-plan rule.

## How does the sell-to-cover exception work?

The sell-to-cover exception covers a plan that "authorizes an agent to sell only such securities as are necessary to satisfy tax withholding obligations arising exclusively from the vesting of a compensatory award," where the insider does not otherwise control the timing of the sales. RSU and restricted stock vesting are the common cases.

Such a plan can run alongside the person's main diversification plan without breaking the one-plan limit. It still needs to meet the other conditions, including its own cooling-off period, to rely on the defense.

Two limits apply. First, a plan that can sell more than the withholding amount is not a sell-to-cover plan; it is a second plan. Second, the SEC declined to extend the exception to option exercises, because exercise timing is the insider's decision. Sales to cover option-exercise taxes can be written into the main plan instead.

## How does a later-commencing plan work?

The later-commencing exception lets a person adopt one replacement plan before the current plan ends, so selling can continue without a gap. The new plan's trading must not be authorized to begin until all trades under the earlier plan are completed or expired without execution.

The catch arises if the earlier plan is terminated early. The rule then asks whether the new plan's first scheduled trade falls within the "effective cooling-off period," measured as if the new plan had been adopted on the date the earlier plan was terminated. The SEC's release gives an example for an employee who is not an officer: the earlier plan's last trade is set for May 31, the later plan is adopted May 1 with a first trade on June 1, and the earlier plan is terminated on May 15. Because June 1 is within 30 days of May 15, the later plan loses the defense. A first trade on July 1 would have been outside the period.

For a director or officer, the effective cooling-off period is the longer 90-to-120-day period, so an early termination of the first plan puts a later plan at much greater risk.

## How does the single-trade limit work?

The single-trade limit applies to a plan "designed to effect the open-market purchase or sale of the total amount of securities as a single transaction." Such a plan gets the defense only if the person has not adopted another single-trade plan in the prior 12 months. Sell-to-cover plans are excluded.

A hypothetical: a chief executive wants to sell 10,000 shares on one future date. A single-trade plan does that. The executive can later adopt a multi-trade plan, subject to the one-plan rule. A second single-trade plan within 12 months of the first would not get the defense.

The test looks at design. A plan written to sell in several transactions is not a single-trade plan merely because the broker happened to fill the whole order at once.

## How can one plan cover several goals?

The one-plan rule pushes insiders to consolidate their selling into one well-designed plan, with a sell-to-cover plan alongside where useful. Common designs:

- **Layered schedule.** Regular monthly or quarterly sales by share count or dollar amount, plus limit-price layers that sell more when the stock is strong.
- **Event coverage.** Sales sized for known needs, such as an estimated tax payment date, written into the same plan.
- **Option exercises.** Exercises and the sales that pay their strike and taxes, in the same plan.
- **Sell-to-cover alongside.** A separate plan limited to withholding at RSU vesting, under the exception.

A simple fixed-dollar plan might sell $50,000 of stock on the 15th of each month. A more complex one adds limit layers and a cap on total shares. Either way, the goal is a single document that covers everything the insider expects to sell over the plan's life.

## How do modifications interact with the one-plan rule?

Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)(iv) treats any change to amount, price or timing as a termination of the plan and the adoption of a new one. The modified plan is still one plan, so a modification does not break the one-plan limit, but it does start a new cooling-off period: for 2026, the later of 90 days or two business days after the quarter's 10-Q or 10-K, capped at 120 days, for directors and officers, and 30 days for others.

Administrative changes that do not affect amount, price or timing, such as a broker's contact details, are not modifications. Normal execution of scheduled trades is not a modification either.

Because the brokers in a multi-broker plan are treated as one plan, a change to any one broker's contract is a change to the whole plan, with the same consequences.

## Which mistakes come up most with multiple plans?

The most common mistakes:

- **A backup plan.** Adopting a second plan "in case" the first does not fill creates two outstanding plans, unless the second is a true later-commencing plan.
- **A broad "sell-to-cover" plan.** If the plan can sell more than the withholding due at vesting, it is a second plan.
- **A separate sell-to-cover plan for option exercises.** The exception does not extend to exercises.
- **Repeated single-trade plans.** A second single-trade plan within 12 months does not get the defense.
- **Ending the first plan early without checking the second.** Early termination can pull a later-commencing plan's first trade inside the effective cooling-off period.
- **Uncoordinated brokers.** Several brokers are allowed, but their contracts must together meet the conditions, and a change to one is a change to all.

## Questions people ask next

### Can my spouse have a separate 10b5-1 plan?

A spouse is a separate person and can adopt a separate 10b5-1 plan for the spouse's own account. For a Section 16 officer, securities held by immediate family members sharing the same household are presumed to be beneficially owned by the officer for reporting purposes, so the spouse's trades may appear on the officer's Form 4. Counsel usually reviews how the two plans relate.

### Can I trade outside my 10b5-1 plan during an open window?

Rule 10b5-1 does not forbid trades outside a plan. Those trades simply get no help from the affirmative defense and are judged on whether the person was aware of material nonpublic information when trading. They also need to follow the company's insider trading policy, which usually means an open window and pre-clearance for officers and many senior employees.

### Do employees below officer level face the same one-plan limit?

The 10b5-1 one-plan limit applies to every person other than the issuer, including employees who are not directors or officers. The difference for those employees is the 30-day cooling-off period, the absence of a written certification and the absence of Item 408(a) public disclosure. The overlapping-plan and single-trade conditions are the same for everyone.

### Can I adopt a new 10b5-1 plan while my current plan is still running?

A new 10b5-1 plan can be adopted while the current one is running if the new plan is a later-commencing plan: its trading cannot begin until every trade under the current plan is complete or has expired. If the current plan is terminated early, the new plan keeps the defense only if its first trade falls outside the cooling-off period measured from the termination date.

### Does the 10b5-1 one-plan limit apply to private companies?

The one-plan limit applies to plans for purchases or sales of a company's securities on the open market. Private-company shares have no open market in the usual sense, so the issue rarely arises before a listing. Once a company lists, its employees' plans follow the company's insider trading policy and the full Rule 10b5-1 conditions.

## Sources

1. [17 CFR 240.10b5-1 (eCFR)](https://www.ecfr.gov/api/renderer/v1/content/enhanced/current/title-17?part=240&section=240.10b5-1)
   > no purchases or sales occur until expiration of a cooling-off period consisting of the later of: (i) Ninety days after the adoption of the contract, instruction, or plan or
2. [SEC Release 33-11138, any class of securities](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/12/29/2022-27675/insider-trading-arrangements-and-related-disclosures)
   > so that the multiple overlapping plans restriction will apply to contracts, instructions or plans for any class of securities of the issuer.
3. [17 CFR 240.16a-1(a)(2)(ii)(A), household family members](https://www.ecfr.gov/api/renderer/v1/content/enhanced/current/title-17?part=240&section=240.16a-1)
   > Securities held by members of a person's immediate family sharing the same household; provided, however, that the presumption of such beneficial ownership may be rebutted
