# The 409A Valuation Problem for NSOs: Why Under-FMV Strikes Are Section 409A Failures

URL: https://vestedgrant.com/equity-comp/409a-problem-nso
Updated 2026-11-21 · Facts checked 2026-11-21 · Tax year 2026

An NSO granted with a strike below the stock's fair market value on the grant date is deferred compensation under Section 409A. Vested spread becomes taxable each year, plus a 20% additional tax and interest, unless the strike is fixed in time.

## Answer

A nonstatutory stock option escapes Section 409A only if its exercise price can never be less than the stock's fair market value on the grant date. A below-value strike makes the option deferred compensation: vested spread is taxed as income, plus a 20% additional tax and interest at the underpayment rate plus 1 percentage point. IRS Notice 2008-113 lets the strike be reset before exercise, generally by the end of the year after grant.

## Key takeaways

- Treasury Regulation 1.409A-1(b)(5)(i)(A) excludes an NSO from Section 409A only if the exercise price may never be less than the stock's fair market value on the grant date and the share count is fixed at grant.
- When a plan fails Section 409A, vested deferred amounts are included in income and the tax rises by 20% of that amount plus interest at the underpayment rate plus 1 percentage point.
- Proposed regulations from 2008 measure the amount deferred under an option as its spread on the last day of the taxable year, so a failing option can be taxed in several years before exercise.
- IRS Notice 2008-113 treats a below-value strike as never having been deferred compensation if it is reset to at least grant-date value before exercise: by the end of the grant year for insiders, or the following year for others.
- A private company's valuation is presumed reasonable if it is an independent appraisal dated no more than 12 months before the grant, among other methods, unless the IRS shows it was grossly unreasonable.

Consider a founder who, on September 15, 2025, grants 48,000 NSOs to a senior engineer with a strike of $2.40. The $2.40 came from a valuation completed before a recent tender offer at a much higher price. An appraisal later prepared as of the grant date puts the common stock at $4.80. The grant was priced $2.40 below fair market value, a spread of $115,200 across the whole grant, and that makes the option deferred compensation under Section 409A of the Internal Revenue Code.

Section 409A, added in 2004, governs nonqualified deferred compensation. An option on the employer's stock is excluded from Section 409A only if its exercise price can never be less than the stock's fair market value on the grant date. A strike below that value brings the option into Section 409A, where it almost always fails the payment-timing rules and triggers extra tax for the employee. This article explains the rule, what failure costs, how valuations go wrong and how a grant can be corrected.

## When is a stock option outside Section 409A?

Treasury Regulation 1.409A-1(b)(5)(i)(A) says an option on service recipient stock does not provide for a deferral of compensation if all three conditions are met:

1. The exercise price may never be less than the fair market value of the underlying stock on the date of grant, and the number of shares is fixed on the original grant date.
2. The transfer or exercise of the option is taxed under Section 83.
3. The option has no other feature for deferring compensation beyond the right to delay income until exercise.

"Service recipient stock" generally means common stock of the employer or a company in its chain of ownership. If any condition fails, the regulation says the option "generally will provide for the deferral of compensation," and it must then meet Section 409A's rules on the timing of payments. A typical option, which can be exercised whenever the holder chooses, does not meet those rules.

Incentive stock options and options under a Section 423 employee stock purchase plan are separately excluded: their grant "does not constitute a deferral of compensation." The Section 409A problem in this article is therefore mostly an NSO problem.

## What happens when an option fails Section 409A?

When a plan fails Section 409A, the statute makes "all compensation deferred under the plan for the taxable year and all preceding taxable years" includible in income for the year, to the extent it is vested and not already taxed. Two additions follow:

- An additional tax equal to 20% of the amount included in income.
- Interest at the IRS underpayment rate plus 1 percentage point, on the underpayments that would have occurred had the amount been taxed when first deferred or, if later, when it vested.

For options, the question is how much has been "deferred." Proposed regulations issued in December 2008 measure an outstanding option by its spread on the last day of each taxable year: the stock's value that day minus the exercise price. Those rules are not final, but they show the shape of the problem. A failing option can produce taxable income in each year it is outstanding and vested, before the employee has exercised it or sold anything.

The employee bears these taxes. The company has reporting and withholding obligations, and correcting the grant usually costs it money and goodwill, but the 20% additional tax falls on the option holder.

## What does that mean in the hypothetical grant?

Continue the hypothetical: 48,000 NSOs granted September 15, 2025 at $2.40, with grant-date value of $4.80, vesting 25% after one year and monthly after that.

| Date | Vested options | Hypothetical stock value | Spread on vested options |
|---|---|---|---|
| December 31, 2025 | 0 | $4.80 | $0 |
| December 31, 2026 | 15,000 | $6.00 | $54,000 |

If the grant is never corrected, the proposed-regulation approach would include $54,000 in the engineer's 2026 income. On top of ordinary income tax at the engineer's 2026 rate, the 20% additional tax is $10,800, plus premium interest. The following year, the increase in spread on vested options would be measured again.

The vesting schedule and the $6.00 value are assumptions for illustration. The point is the pattern: tax on paper gains, year after year, without a sale to pay for it.

## How do private companies set fair market value?

For stock that is not readily tradable, the regulation requires "the reasonable application of a reasonable valuation method," taking into account assets, expected cash flows, comparable companies, recent arm's-length sales of the stock, control premiums and discounts for lack of marketability. Three methods are presumed reasonable unless the IRS shows the method or its application was grossly unreasonable:

| Method | Key conditions |
|---|---|
| Independent appraisal | Meets the Section 401(a)(28)(C) appraisal standards; valuation date no more than 12 months before the grant |
| Formula price | Used for a nonlapse restriction and applied consistently to all transfers of the stock to the company or 10% owners |
| Illiquid start-up report | Written, reasonable and in good faith; company has conducted no material business for 10 years or more and has no publicly traded equity; valuer has significant experience, generally at least five years; no change in control expected within 90 days or public offering within 180 days |

For stock that is readily tradable, fair market value can be set from actual trades, such as the closing price on the trading day before or the day of the grant, or an average over a pre-set period of up to 30 days.

## Why do valuations go stale?

A common source of Section 409A pricing errors at private companies is a valuation used after it has stopped being reasonable. The regulation says a previously calculated value is not reasonable at a later date if it "fails to reflect information available after the date of the calculation that may materially affect the value," or if it was calculated as of a date more than 12 months earlier.

Events that commonly make a valuation stale include:

- A priced financing round, especially one well above the prior round
- A tender offer or secondary sale at a price above the current common-stock value
- A sharp change in revenue, customers or competitive position
- Material litigation resolved, or a key patent issued
- Serious acquisition or IPO activity

The hypothetical grant is the classic case: the valuation was less than 12 months old, but a tender offer at a higher price had already happened. Continuing to use the old number after that event is what creates the error.

## Which other patterns cause below-value strikes?

Stale valuations are the most common source of below-value strikes, but not the only one:

- **Repricing below current value.** Lowering the exercise price of an existing option is a "modification" under the regulation, which treats it as the grant of a new stock right on that date; if the new price is below that day's value, the option fails. Cancelling an underwater option and granting a new one at current value avoids that problem, because the new option is priced on its own grant date.
- **Discounted grants by design.** Some companies have offered options below current value as a recruiting feature. Unless structured to meet Section 409A's payment rules, these fail from the start, and the cost falls on the employee.
- **Corporate transactions.** When options are substituted or assumed in a merger, the regulation allows the swap without a new grant only if it follows the rules for substitutions that preserve the spread and ratio.
- **Administrative mistakes.** The wrong grant date, the wrong valuation or a typo in the strike can all produce a below-value price.

## How can a below-value strike be corrected?

IRS Notice 2008-113 lets a company treat a below-value option as never having provided deferred compensation if the strike is reset to at least the grant-date fair market value in time:

| Who holds the option | Deadline to reset the strike |
|---|---|
| Any service provider | Before exercise and by the end of the holder's taxable year in which the option was granted |
| Non-insider service provider | Before exercise and by the end of the holder's taxable year immediately following the year of grant |

"Insiders" under the notice are directors, officers and owners of more than 10% of any class of equity, determined under the SEC's Section 16 rules even if the company is private. The notice also has procedural conditions, including a statement the company attaches to its tax return for some corrections.

In the hypothetical, the engineer is not an insider and the grant was made in 2025, so resetting the strike from $2.40 to $4.80 by December 31, 2026, before any exercise, would bring the option back outside Section 409A. Raising a strike takes value from the employee, so companies often pay something for the employee's consent, such as a cash bonus equal to the lost spread or an additional grant. Those payments are taxed in their own right.

Once both deadlines pass, the options narrow. Cancelling the option and granting a new one at current value stops future problems but does not undo inclusions already required for earlier years.

The [409A valuations article](https://vestedgrant.com/equity-comp/409a-valuations-nso-grants) covers how valuations are built and what they mean for employees receiving NSO grants.

## Questions people ask next

### Does Section 409A apply to ISOs?

The grant of an incentive stock option under Section 422 is not a deferral of compensation under the Section 409A regulations. An ISO must have an exercise price of at least the stock's fair market value at grant; if a good-faith attempt to value the stock fails, Section 422(c)(1) treats that requirement as met. An option that does not qualify as an ISO is tested as an NSO under Section 409A.

### Is an NSO with a strike exactly at fair market value safe under Section 409A?

An NSO whose exercise price equals the stock's fair market value on the grant date meets the Section 409A exclusion, as long as the share count is fixed at grant and the option has no other deferral feature. The risk lies in how fair market value was set: a stale or unreasonable valuation can mean the price that looked equal was actually below value.

### Can I still exercise an NSO that has a Section 409A problem?

An NSO with a Section 409A problem can usually still be exercised under its terms, but the exercise affects the fix. IRS Notice 2008-113 corrections require the strike to be reset before the option is exercised, so exercising first can rule out that route for the exercised shares. The holder should ask the company how it plans to correct the grant before exercising.

### Does Section 409A apply to RSUs?

RSUs that deliver shares soon after vesting usually fall under the short-term deferral exception in Treasury Regulation 1.409A-1(b)(4), which covers payments made by the 15th day of the third month after the end of the year in which the right vests. RSUs that defer delivery beyond that window, for example until a later fixed date, must meet the Section 409A rules.

### How is the amount taxed under Section 409A measured for an option?

Proposed regulations issued in December 2008 measure the amount deferred under an outstanding option as its spread on the last day of the taxable year: the stock's fair market value minus the exercise price, for vested options. Those rules have not been finalized, but they explain why a failing option can create taxable income in several years before it is exercised.

## Sources

1. [26 CFR 1.409A-1(b)(5)(i)(A), NSOs excluded from 409A](https://www.ecfr.gov/api/renderer/v1/content/enhanced/current/title-26?part=1&section=1.409A-1)
   > The exercise price may never be less than the fair market value of the underlying stock (disregarding lapse restrictions as defined in § 1.83-3(i) ) on the date the option is granted
2. [26 U.S.C. 409A(a)(1)(A), income inclusion](https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/t26/s409A)
   > all compensation deferred under the plan for the taxable year and all preceding taxable years shall be includible in gross income for the taxable year to the extent not subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture
3. [Proposed income inclusion regulations under Section 409A (Federal Register, December 8, 2008)](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2008/12/08/E8-28894/further-guidance-on-the-application-of-section-409a-to-nonqualified-deferred-compensation-plans)
   > the total amount deferred under an outstanding stock right is the amount of money and the fair market value of the property that the service provider would receive by exercising the right on the last day of the taxable year
4. [IRS Notice 2008-113, section IV.D (same-year correction)](https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/n-08-113.pdf)
   > Before the stock right is exercised and not later than the last day of the service provider’s taxable year in which the service recipient granted the service provider the stock right
5. [26 U.S.C. 422(b)(4) and (c)(1), ISO exercise price](https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/t26/s422)
   > the option price is not less than the fair market value of the stock at the time such option is granted
