# Private-Company RSU Valuation: 409A vs Last Tender vs Preferred Round

URL: https://vestedgrant.com/equity-comp/pre-ipo-rsu-valuation
Updated 2026-11-21 · Facts checked 2026-11-21 · Tax year 2026

Pre-IPO RSUs have three different valuations floating around: the 409A, the last tender price and the preferred round. None of them sets the W-2 income when a double-trigger RSU settles; the value on the settlement date does.

## Answer

The taxable value of a pre-IPO RSU is the fair market value of the shares on the day they are delivered, not the grant-date 409A, the last tender price or the preferred round price. For a double-trigger RSU that settles after an IPO, that is the trading value on the plan's settlement date; in an acquisition, it is the deal consideration. For 2026, supplemental withholding on that income is 22% up to $1 million and 37% above.

## Key takeaways

- A 409A value is presumed reasonable when it comes from an independent appraisal dated no more than 12 months before the grant it is used for.
- An option is exempt from § 409A only if its exercise price can never be less than the fair market value of the stock on the grant date, which is why the 409A sets option strikes.
- Double-trigger RSUs are taxed as wages on the value delivered at settlement, so a 409A from years earlier has no effect on the W-2 amount.
- For 2026, federal supplemental withholding on RSU income is 22% on the first $1 million in the year and a mandatory 37% above $1 million.
- Social Security and Medicare can apply to deferred stock compensation when it is no longer subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture, under 26 U.S.C. § 3121(v)(2).

Consider a hypothetical product manager at a Series E AI company who received 4,000 RSUs in 2024. The grant agreement names a share count, not a dollar value. The 409A value on the grant date was $12.40. The most recent tender offer, three months earlier, cleared at $28 per share. The Series E preferred shares were priced at $42. Three numbers for the same share, and no obvious answer to which one matters when the RSUs settle.

The answer is the value on the settlement date. When a double-trigger RSU settles after an IPO, the taxable amount is the fair market value of the shares delivered on the settlement date the plan defines. When it settles in an acquisition, it is the per-share deal consideration. The grant-date 409A, the tender price and the preferred round price are signals about value, but none of them is the number that becomes W-2 wages.

## What does each of the three valuations measure?

Each number answers a different question about the same company.

### What is the 409A value?

A 409A value is an independent appraisal of a private company's common stock, used to set option exercise prices at or above fair market value. Treasury Regulation § 1.409A-1(b)(5)(iv)(B) presumes the value reasonable if it comes from an independent appraisal dated no more than 12 months before the grant, so companies refresh it at least once a year and after material events.

For RSUs, which have no exercise price, the 409A matters mainly if shares are delivered while the company is still private, for example under a single-trigger RSU. The appraisal values common stock and applies discounts for lack of marketability and lack of control, so it sits below the preferred round price.

### What does the last tender price show?

A tender offer lets existing holders sell shares to the company or an outside investor at a price the board approves. Tender prices are actual transactions in common stock, which makes them useful evidence of what sophisticated buyers pay for illiquid shares. They usually land between the 409A value and the preferred price, because buyers accept illiquidity but are pricing in an expected exit.

A tender price affects an RSU holder's taxes only if RSUs settle in connection with the tender.

### What does the preferred round price measure?

The preferred price is the headline number. Press reports multiply it by the fully diluted share count to produce a valuation, which treats every share as if it carried preferred rights. Preferred stock has liquidation preferences, often anti-dilution protection and protective votes that common stock lacks, so a common share is worth less than a preferred share in the same company.

## Which valuation sets the taxable income when an RSU settles?

The fair market value on the settlement date sets the income. Settlement is the day the second trigger has occurred and shares are delivered. For a double-trigger RSU that settles after an IPO, the plan defines the settlement date and how the value is measured, commonly a trading price on or near that date. For an RSU settled in an acquisition, the value is the per-share merger consideration, often a mix of cash and acquirer stock.

Earlier 409A values are not applied retroactively. If the hypothetical RSUs granted at a $12.40 409A value settle when the shares are worth $42, the W-2 income is $42 per share.

Federal withholding on that income uses the supplemental wage rules: for 2026, 22% on supplemental wages up to $1 million in the calendar year and a mandatory 37% above $1 million. Social Security tax (6.2% up to the $184,500 wage base for 2026) and Medicare tax (1.45%, plus 0.9% additional Medicare tax on wages above $200,000) also apply. Under 26 U.S.C. § 3121(v)(2), deferred compensation can be counted for Social Security and Medicare when it stops being subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture, which for some double-trigger designs is earlier than income tax settlement.

## What changes when the settlement consideration is not cash?

An all-cash acquisition is simple: the per-share cash price is the value. Deals paid partly in acquirer stock or with earnouts are harder.

For the stock portion, the plan or deal documents set how the acquirer stock is valued, commonly by its trading price at closing. Earnout payments that depend on future results may be paid, and taxed, in later years, and the plan documents decide whether unvested RSUs are converted into acquirer awards, paid out or canceled. Under the short-term deferral rule in Treasury Regulation § 1.409A-1(b)(4), payments made within the applicable 2½ month period after vesting are not deferred compensation, which is why many plans settle promptly after the trigger.

## Why does the gap between perceived value and taxable value matter?

A holder who sees a $42 preferred price may think 4,000 RSUs are worth $168,000 today. They are a contract right to receive shares later. No income has been recognized, no tax is owed and nothing can be sold. The gap between the headline value and the settlement value matters in several places.

**Borrowing.** A loan application asks for income and assets. Unsettled double-trigger RSUs have produced no income, and lenders set their own rules on whether and how equity compensation counts. Presenting the preferred-round value of unsettled RSUs as income or assets can mislead an underwriter.

**Estate planning.** Most RSU agreements prohibit transfers, so RSUs generally cannot be given away before settlement. After settlement, the delivered shares can be transferred like other stock, subject to the stockholder agreement, and are valued for gift tax at their fair market value on the gift date.

**Divorce.** State courts value and divide unvested equity in different ways, often using time-based fractions to separate the marital share. Because no market price exists, the value used is usually an estimate of common stock value at a chosen date, closer to the 409A than to the preferred price.

## What does the 409A actually control for a pre-IPO employee?

The 409A sets the taxable amount only when shares or options change hands while the company is private.

| Situation | Role of the 409A value |
|---|---|
| ISO exercise | Value at exercise sets the AMT adjustment |
| NSO exercise | Value at exercise sets ordinary income |
| Single-trigger RSU settlement | Value at settlement sets wage income |
| New option grant | Sets the minimum exercise price |
| Double-trigger RSU before the liquidity event | No tax effect for the employee |

Each refresh produces a new value that applies to grants and exercises going forward. A financing round, a secondary sale at a different price, or a change in the company's outlook can each prompt a refresh.

## How do the three values usually move as an IPO approaches?

The gap between the 409A value and the preferred price is usually widest early in a company's life and narrows as an exit becomes more likely. Early on, the chance of a sale below the preference stack is high and the time to liquidity is long, so common stock carries large discounts. As an IPO nears, the chance that preferred converts to common rises, the expected wait shortens, and the appraised value of common moves closer to the preferred price. At the IPO itself, preferred usually converts and the distinction disappears.

The exact ratio between the two varies by company, round terms and appraiser, so a published "typical" ratio is a weak substitute for the company's own 409A report and cap table.

## How should the different values be used in planning?

Each value answers a different planning question.

For a possible secondary sale or tender, the tender price is the closest guide to what a buyer will pay, because it reflects real transactions in common stock.

For the tax year of an IPO, the relevant number is the expected trading price on the settlement date, not the preferred price or the 409A. The gap between a private round and a public price can run in either direction, so tax reserves are often modeled at several share prices.

For comparing a pre-IPO offer with a public company offer, the preferred-round value overstates what common stock and unsettled RSUs are worth to an employee. The [pre-IPO equity value calculator](https://vestedgrant.com/calculators/secondary-sale) adjusts for the preference stack and dilution to produce a range rather than a single headline figure.

## Questions people ask next

### Why is a startup's 409A value so much lower than the valuation reported in the press?

The 409A appraises common stock, which has no liquidation preference, while press valuations multiply the latest preferred share price by the fully diluted share count, treating every share as if it were preferred. Preferred stock is paid first in a sale and often has other protections, so a common share is worth less than a preferred share in the same company. The gap tends to narrow as an IPO approaches.

### Can unsettled pre-IPO RSUs be sold in a tender offer?

Generally not. An unsettled RSU is a contract right to receive shares later, not a share, and tender offers buy shares. Some companies settle vested RSUs in connection with a tender so that employees can sell the delivered shares, which creates wage income at settlement. Whether that happens is set by the tender documents and the RSU plan, so eligibility differs from company to company.

### How does the 409A relate to option strike prices?

Under the § 409A regulations, a nonstatutory option avoids being treated as deferred compensation only if its exercise price can never be less than the stock's fair market value on the grant date. Incentive stock options have a similar requirement under § 422. A private company uses its 409A appraisal as that fair market value, so new options are typically granted at the current 409A price.

### Does a down round change the tax on existing RSUs?

A down round does not change the terms of RSUs already granted. Each RSU remains a right to receive a share, and the taxable value is set by the share value on the settlement date. A lower valuation affects new grants, and if the low value persists to the liquidity event, the settlement income is lower too, as is the tax.

### What happens to RSU taxes if the IPO prices below the last preferred round?

Wage income at settlement equals the value of the shares actually delivered on the settlement date, whatever the preferred round price was. If the stock trades below the last private round when the RSUs settle, the W-2 income and the tax are lower. No tax is owed on the higher value the shares might once have been expected to reach.

## Sources

1. [IRS Publication 15 (2026), (Circular E), Employer's Tax Guide](https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p15.pdf)
   > The withholding rate on supplemental wages remains 22% (37% if supplemental wages paid to an employee during the calendar year exceed $1 million) because P.L. 119-21 permanently extended the individual tax rates
2. [IRS Topic no. 560, Additional Medicare tax](https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc560)
   > A 0.9% Additional Medicare tax applies to Medicare wages, self-employment income, and railroad retirement (RRTA) compensation that exceed the following threshold amounts based on filing status:
3. [Treas. Reg. § 1.409A-1(b)(5)(iv)(B) (Valuation of service recipient stock), eCFR](https://www.ecfr.gov/api/renderer/v1/content/enhanced/current/title-26?part=1&section=1.409A-1)
   > A valuation of a class of stock determined by an independent appraisal that meets the requirements of section 401(a)(28)(C) and the regulations as of a date that is no more than 12 months before the relevant transaction
4. [26 U.S.C. § 3121(v)(2) (Treatment of certain nonqualified deferred compensation)](https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/t26/s3121)
   > shall be taken into account for purposes of this chapter as of the later of (i) when the services are performed, or (ii) when there is no substantial risk of forfeiture of the rights to such amount
