# Section 83(i) Deferred-Compensation Election for Private-Company Employees

URL: https://vestedgrant.com/equity-comp/section-83i-deferred-election
Updated 2026-11-21 · Facts checked 2026-11-21 · Tax year 2026

Section 83(i) lets certain private-company employees defer income tax on RSU settlement or option exercise for up to five years. Few employees can use it because the employer must set up an 80% grant plan and an escrow.

## Answer

Section 83(i) lets a qualified employee of a private company defer federal income tax on stock received from an option exercise or RSU settlement for up to five years, or until an earlier event such as an IPO. The deferred income is fixed at the vest-date value, FICA is still due at vest, and withholding at the inclusion date runs at the top rate, 37% for 2026.

## Key takeaways

- Section 83(i) defers federal income tax on private-company option or RSU stock for up to five years after the stock vests.
- A company qualifies only if a written plan grants options or RSUs with the same rights to at least 80% of its U.S. employees in the year.
- The CEO, the CFO, their relatives, 1% owners and the four highest-paid officers can never make a Section 83(i) election.
- FICA taxes on Section 83(i) stock are still due at vesting; only the federal income tax is deferred.
- IRS Notice 2018-97 lets an employer block the election simply by declining to set up the required escrow for deferral stock.

Section 83(i), added by the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, allows certain private-company employees to defer federal income tax on stock received from an option exercise or RSU settlement for up to five years. The provision targets a specific problem: an employee at a private company owes ordinary income tax when RSUs settle or nonqualified options are exercised, but often cannot sell the illiquid stock to pay that tax.

In practice the election is rare. The employer has to meet a broad-based grant test, hand out a statutory notice, and agree to hold the deferral stock in escrow, and IRS guidance lets an employer block the election simply by not setting up that escrow. This article walks through the Section 83(i) framework, the 2026 tax math, and the reasons employers and employees seldom use it.

## What does a Section 83(i) election do?

A Section 83(i) election moves the year in which stock compensation is taxed, without changing the amount. Normally, under Section 83(a), an employee includes the value of stock in income when it vests or is received. With a Section 83(i) election, that same amount is included in a later year: the year of the earliest of five events listed in the statute, with five years after vesting as the outer limit.

Three features define the election:

- **The amount is frozen at vesting.** The income recognized at the end of the deferral is the value of the stock when it first became transferable or vested, even if the stock later falls. The statute requires the employer to warn employees of exactly this.
- **Only income tax is deferred.** IRS Notice 2018-97 confirms that Social Security and Medicare (FICA) taxes on deferral stock are unaffected, so they are still due at vest.
- **Withholding at the end is at the top rate.** Section 3402(t) sets withholding on Section 83(i) stock at no less than the maximum individual rate, which is 37% for 2026.

Appreciation after vesting is not part of the deferred amount. Basis in the stock equals the amount included in income, and a later sale produces capital gain or loss measured from that basis.

## Which companies count as eligible corporations?

A company is an eligible corporation for a calendar year only if two conditions hold. First, no stock of the corporation, or of any predecessor, was readily tradable on an established securities market during any preceding calendar year. Second, the corporation has a written plan under which, in that year, at least 80% of all employees who provide services in the United States are granted stock options, or are granted RSUs, with the same rights and privileges to receive qualified stock.

The 80% test has details that make it hard to meet:

- **Options and RSUs do not mix.** The statute says rights to exercise an option are not the same as rights to settle an RSU, so a company granting options to some staff and RSUs to others cannot add the two groups together.
- **Share counts may differ.** Employees can receive different numbers of shares, as long as each employee's amount is more than de minimis.
- **Some employees are left out of the count.** Excluded employees and certain part-time employees are not counted in the 80% base.
- **The grant year matters.** Stock is qualified only if the option or RSU was granted in a calendar year when the company was an eligible corporation.

A company whose equity program covers only engineers, only senior staff, or a mix of options and RSUs across the workforce generally fails the 80% test. Companies in the same controlled group are treated as one corporation.

## Which employees can make the Section 83(i) election?

A qualified employee is anyone who is not an excluded employee and who agrees, in the election, to the withholding arrangements the Treasury requires. The excluded employee list is permanent in practice, because most categories look back ten years or to any prior time:

| Excluded group | Look-back period |
|---|---|
| 1-percent owners | The current year or any of the 10 preceding calendar years |
| Chief executive officer or chief financial officer, or anyone acting in that role | Any prior time |
| Family members of the CEO or CFO under Section 318(a)(1) | Any time the relationship exists |
| The 4 highest compensated officers | The current year or any of the 10 preceding taxable years |

The four highest compensated officers are identified using the SEC proxy disclosure rules, applied as if the company were public. An employee who becomes an excluded employee after making the election triggers immediate inclusion, which is one of the five events that end the deferral.

For a typical engineer, product manager or mid-level manager at a late-stage private company, the excluded categories rarely apply. The practical obstacle for those employees is whether the employer has created the conditions for the election at all.

## How and when is the Section 83(i) election made?

The employee files a Section 83(i) election no later than 30 days after the first date the stock becomes transferable or is no longer subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture, whichever comes first. The statute says the election is made in a manner similar to a Section 83(b) election.

Several conditions can block the election entirely:

- **A prior 83(b) election.** No Section 83(i) election is allowed for stock on which the employee already made a Section 83(b) election.
- **Any public trading.** No election is allowed if any stock of the company was readily tradable on an established market before the election is made.
- **Company buybacks.** No election is allowed if the company repurchased any of its stock in the prior calendar year, unless at least 25% of the dollar amount bought back was deferral stock and the sellers were chosen on a reasonable basis.
- **The escrow.** Under IRS Notice 2018-97, the employee must agree in the election that the deferral stock will be held in an escrow arrangement. The escrow lets the company keep enough shares at the inclusion date to cover its income tax withholding. If the company and employee do not agree to that escrow, the employee is not a qualified employee.

The employer also has a notice duty. A company transferring qualified stock must certify that it is qualified stock and tell the employee that the deferred income is fixed at the vest-date value and subject to withholding at the top rate.

## When does Section 83(i) deferred income become taxable?

The deferred income is included in the taxable year that contains the earliest of five dates set out in Section 83(i)(1)(B):

1. The first date the stock becomes transferable, including transferable to the employer.
2. The date the employee first becomes an excluded employee.
3. The first date any stock of the company becomes readily tradable on an established securities market, which in practice means an IPO or direct listing.
4. The date five years after the stock first became transferable or vested, whichever was earlier.
5. The date the employee revokes the election.

The IPO trigger deserves attention. Inclusion happens when the company's stock first trades, which is usually while employees are still subject to a lockup. The employee can owe the deferred tax, with withholding at the top rate taken from escrowed shares, at a time when the remaining shares cannot yet be sold.

At inclusion, ordinary income equals the vest-date value, not the value on the inclusion date. If the stock rose, the extra value is outside the deferred amount and is taxed only when the shares are sold. If the stock fell, the employee still includes the full vest-date value.

## What does Section 83(i) deferral save in a 2026 example?

Take a hypothetical single engineer at a private company with a $250,000 salary in 2026 whose RSUs settle 20,000 shares at a fair market value of $25, which adds $500,000 of ordinary income. The figures below use 2026 federal brackets and the 2026 standard deduction of $16,100; state tax is left out.

| 2026 federal item | Without election | With Section 83(i) election |
|---|---|---|
| Federal income tax on the $500,000, due for 2026 | $176,196 | $0 (deferred) |
| Medicare tax at vest (1.45% plus 0.9% Additional Medicare) | $11,750 | $11,750 |
| Social Security tax at vest | $0 (salary already above the $184,500 wage base) | $0 |
| Federal income tax due at the inclusion date | None | About $176,196 if rates and income are unchanged |

The $176,196 is the difference between federal tax on taxable income of $733,900 ($192,979.25 plus 37% of the amount over $640,600, or $227,500.25) and on $233,900 ($41,024 plus 32% of the amount over $201,775, or $51,304). Withholding at inclusion would be 37% of $500,000, or $185,000, with any excess refunded on that year's return.

The value of deferral is the time value of money plus liquidity. Discounting $176,196 paid five years later at a hypothetical 5% annual rate gives a present value of about $138,050, a benefit of roughly $38,150. The larger benefit is often not having to find $176,196 of cash in a year when the shares cannot be sold.

## What happens to post-vest growth in the example?

Growth after vesting is taxed the same way with or without the election. If the hypothetical company later goes public and the engineer eventually sells the 20,000 shares at $80, the gain over the $25 basis is $1,100,000. Assuming the gain falls in the 20% long-term bracket and above the 3.8% net investment income tax threshold, a combined 23.8% using 2026 rates, the federal tax on that gain is $261,800.

That figure does not change with the election, because Section 83(i) moves only the timing of the $500,000 vest-date income. What does change is the order of cash needs. Without the election, the engineer owes $176,196 for 2026 with no market for the shares. With the election, the same $176,196 is due in the year of the IPO, when there is at least a prospect of selling shares after any lockup ends.

## When does a Section 83(i) election cost more than it saves?

The election can lose money or create a worse cash problem in four situations.

1. **The tax rate is higher in the inclusion year.** The deferred income is taxed at the rates and in the bracket of the year it is included. A move from a state without income tax to one with a high rate, or a large bonus or home sale in the inclusion year, can make the same $500,000 cost more.

2. **The stock falls during deferral.** The amount included is fixed at the vest-date value. If the hypothetical $25 stock is worth $5 at the five-year mark, the engineer still includes $500,000 of income on shares worth $100,000. If the company fails, the employee owes tax on value that no longer exists; any loss on the shares is a capital loss, deductible against ordinary income at only $3,000 a year.

3. **The inclusion date falls at a bad time.** The five-year date, an IPO, or the stock becoming transferable can all arrive in a year with other large income, or during a lockup when shares cannot be sold to pay the tax.

4. **The employer's situation changes.** The escrow and withholding mechanics depend on the employer. An acquisition, a change in plan administration, or a dispute about escrowed shares can complicate the inclusion-year withholding.

## Why do so few employers offer Section 83(i)?

Employers rarely set up the conditions for the election because the cost falls on the company and the benefit on a subset of employees.

1. **The 80% grant rule.** Most private companies do not grant the same kind of award to at least 80% of their U.S. employees in a given year. Meeting the test can require redesigning the equity program.

2. **Escrow and withholding administration.** The employer must hold deferral stock in escrow, track each employee's inclusion date, and withhold at the top rate when the deferral ends. That is a multi-year administrative commitment.

3. **Restrictions on buybacks.** A company with deferral stock outstanding faces limits on repurchasing its own stock, which can conflict with tender offers or other liquidity programs that private companies run for employees.

4. **Limited guidance.** IRS Notice 2018-97 addressed the 80% test, withholding and escrow, and said further guidance was expected. Companies weighing the election face open questions on edge cases.

5. **An easy way out.** Notice 2018-97 says a company can preclude elections by declining to establish the escrow, and grant agreements can state that no Section 83(i) election is available. Doing nothing is therefore a complete answer for most employers.

## Why do eligible employees often skip the Section 83(i) election?

Even where the election is offered, employees have reasons not to file it.

1. **Awareness.** The employer notice is the main way employees learn about Section 83(i), and a notice delivered with routine vesting paperwork is easy to miss.

2. **The 30-day deadline.** The election must be made within 30 days of vesting. An employee who is travelling, changing jobs, or waiting for tax advice can miss the window, and there is no late election.

3. **Coordination.** The employee, the employer's stock plan team and a tax adviser all need to act within that window, and the employee must agree to the escrow terms.

4. **Downside risk.** Employees who think the stock could fall during the deferral period may prefer to recognize the income now rather than risk owing tax on value that later disappears.

5. **Adviser familiarity.** Section 83(i) is used rarely enough that many tax preparers have not handled one, so it is often not raised.

## What should an employee check before relying on Section 83(i)?

An employee at a private company who wants to evaluate the election can work through these points with a tax adviser:

1. **Employer eligibility.** Ask the stock plan administrator whether the company is an eligible corporation for the grant year, whether it has an escrow arrangement, and whether the grant agreement excludes Section 83(i).
2. **Personal eligibility.** Confirm you are not a 1% owner, CEO, CFO, relative of either, or one of the four highest compensated officers in the current or prior ten years.
3. **Cash for FICA now.** Budget for Medicare and any Social Security tax on the vest-date value, which is due at vesting regardless of the election.
4. **Model both years.** Compare the vest-year federal and state tax with an estimate for the likely inclusion year, including the chance that the inclusion year is the IPO year.
5. **Price risk.** Consider what happens if the stock falls, since the deferred income stays at the vest-date value.
6. **File within 30 days.** Make the written election within 30 days of vesting and keep proof of filing.
7. **Track the inclusion dates.** Calendar the five-year date and watch for the other triggers, including an IPO or the stock becoming transferable.

## Questions people ask next

### Can my employer be required to offer a Section 83(i) election?

No employer is required to offer Section 83(i). IRS Notice 2018-97 says a corporation can preclude Section 83(i) elections by declining to set up the escrow arrangement that holds deferral stock, and an option or RSU agreement can state that no Section 83(i) election is available. An employee whose company has not created those conditions has no way to make the election on their own.

### Can I revoke a Section 83(i) election after filing it?

Section 83(i) lists revocation as one of the events that ends the deferral, at such time and in such manner as the Treasury provides. Revoking a Section 83(i) election makes the deferred amount taxable in the year of revocation, still measured at the value the stock had when it vested. The revocation ends the deferral benefit but does not reduce the income.

### Can I use Section 83(i) on incentive stock options?

Section 83(i) covers stock received from exercising an option, which includes an option granted as an ISO, but Section 422(b) says an option stops being an incentive stock option if a Section 83(i) election is made for the stock. The exercise is then taxed like a nonqualified option exercise, with ordinary income on the spread that is deferred rather than an AMT preference item.

### Does a Section 83(i) election defer Social Security and Medicare tax?

A Section 83(i) election defers only federal income tax. IRS Notice 2018-97 states that FICA and FUTA taxation of deferral stock is unaffected, so Social Security and Medicare tax on the vest-date value is due when the stock vests. For 2026, Medicare tax of 1.45%, plus 0.9% Additional Medicare tax on wages above $200,000, applies with no cap.

### Does Section 83(i) defer state income tax too?

State treatment of a Section 83(i) election depends on whether the state conforms to the federal provision, and conformity varies by state. An employee whose state does not follow Section 83(i) may owe state income tax on the vest-date value in the vest year while the federal tax is deferred. The state revenue department or a state tax adviser can confirm the rule for that state.

## Sources

1. [Rev. Proc. 2025-32](https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rp-25-32.pdf)
   > Over $640,600 $192,979.25 plus 37% of the excess over $640,600
2. [IRS Publication 15 (2026), (Circular E), Employer's Tax Guide](https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p15.pdf)
   > The tax rate for Medicare is 1.45% (amount withheld) each for the employee and employer (2.9% total). There is no wage base limit for Medicare tax;
3. [IRS Topic no. 560, Additional Medicare tax](https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc560)
   > A 0.9% Additional Medicare tax applies to Medicare wages, self-employment income, and railroad retirement (RRTA) compensation that exceed the following threshold amounts based on filing status:
4. [IRS Topic no. 559, Net investment income tax](https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc559)
   > A 3.8 percent net investment income tax (NIIT) applies to individuals, estates, and trusts that have net investment income above applicable threshold amounts.
5. [IRS Topic no. 409, Capital gains and losses](https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc409)
   > the amount of the excess loss that you can claim to lower your income is the lesser of $3,000 ($1,500 if married filing separately)
6. [26 U.S.C. § 83(i)(1)(B)(iii), deferral ends when the stock becomes readily tradable](https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/t26/s83)
   > the first date on which any stock of the corporation which issued the qualified stock becomes readily tradable on an established securities market
7. [26 U.S.C. § 3402(t), Rate of withholding for certain stock](https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/t26/s3402)
   > the rate of tax under subsection (a) shall not be less than the maximum rate of tax in effect under section 1
8. [IRS Notice 2018-97](https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/n-18-97.pdf)
   > The Act made no amendments to FICA and FUTA taxation with respect to deferral stock. Thus, the FICA and FUTA taxation of deferral stock is unaffected by the Act.
9. [26 U.S.C. § 422(b), Incentive stock options](https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/t26/s422)
   > Such term shall not include any option if an election is made under section 83(i) with respect to the stock received in connection with the exercise of such option.
