# Valuation Discounts on Pre-IPO Shares in an Estate: DLOC and DLOM

URL: https://vestedgrant.com/estate/valuation-discounts-pre-ipo-estate
Updated 2026-11-21 · Facts checked 2026-11-21 · Tax year 2026

Pre-IPO shares given or left in an estate are valued at what a willing buyer would pay, which is usually below a pro-rata share of the last round price because of discounts for lack of control and lack of marketability. How the discounts work, how they are documented, and how the IRS reviews them.

## Answer

Gift and estate tax value pre-IPO shares at the price a willing buyer would pay a willing seller, not at the last preferred round price. Appraisers usually apply a discount for lack of control and a discount for lack of marketability to minority common stock, and the discounts multiply. A smaller reported value uses less of the 2026 lifetime exclusion of $15 million, so documenting the discounts with a qualified appraisal matters.

## Key takeaways

- Treasury Regulation 25.2512-1 values a gift at the price at which property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, which is why minority, illiquid common stock is discounted.
- Discounts combine multiplicatively: a hypothetical 20% control discount and 25% marketability discount leave 60% of the undiscounted value, a 40% combined discount.
- For 2026, each person can give $19,000 per recipient under the annual exclusion and $15 million in total under the lifetime basic exclusion before federal gift tax applies.
- A gift is adequately disclosed, which starts the three-year assessment period, when the Form 709 describes the discounts claimed or attaches an appraisal by a qualified appraiser.
- No statute fixes discount percentages; the IRS reviews each appraisal against factors such as those in the Mandelbaum Tax Court case.

Consider a hypothetical founder who gives 100,000 common shares of her Series C company to an irrevocable trust. The most recent preferred round priced at $12 per share. Multiplying her common shares by the preferred price gives $1.2 million.

Her appraiser concludes that a buyer of a minority block of common stock would pay less than that. In this illustration the appraiser applies a 20% discount for lack of control, because common lacks the rights of preferred, and a 25% discount for lack of marketability, because the shares cannot be sold freely. Combined, the shares are valued at $720,000 for gift tax purposes.

The gift uses $720,000 of her lifetime exclusion instead of $1.2 million. For 2026 the federal basic exclusion is $15 million per person, so the discount stretches how much stock she can move to the trust before any gift tax is due. For founders planning transfers of pre-IPO stock, understanding and documenting valuation discounts is central to the plan.

## What are DLOC and DLOM?

DLOC and DLOM are the two discounts that bring a minority block of private common stock below its pro-rata share of company value. Both follow from the gift and estate tax standard in Treasury Regulation 25.2512-1: property is valued at the price at which it would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither under compulsion and both with reasonable knowledge of the facts.

**Discount for lack of control (DLOC).** A minority holder cannot direct the company's decisions, so a buyer pays less per share than a buyer acquiring control would. For common stock in a venture-backed company, the reasons are concrete:

- Limited voting power relative to preferred holders and the board.
- No ability to force distributions, a sale of the company or strategic changes.
- Preferred protective provisions that can veto major decisions.

**Discount for lack of marketability (DLOM).** Public shareholders can sell on any trading day at a known price. Private shareholders usually cannot. Transfer restrictions, rights of first refusal and the absence of a market all reduce what a buyer would pay.

No statute or regulation sets the size of either discount. Appraisers support them with empirical studies and company facts, and the IRS reviews them case by case. The percentages in this article are illustrations, not benchmarks.

## How are the two discounts combined?

The discounts multiply rather than add, because the marketability discount is applied to a value that has already been reduced for lack of control. Using the hypothetical founder's figures:

- A 20% DLOC leaves 80% of the undiscounted value.
- A 25% DLOM applied to that 80% leaves 0.75 × 80% = 60%.
- The combined discount is 40%, not the 45% that simple addition would suggest.

Appraisers justify each discount separately because they measure different things: one measures the inability to direct the company, the other the inability to turn the shares into cash. A holder who controls the company may get little or no control discount but still face a marketability discount, and a minority holder in a company with an active, unrestricted secondary market may get a control discount with only a small marketability discount.

The order and method vary by appraiser. Some valuation approaches, such as option-pricing allocations used for common stock, already build part of the preferred-versus-common difference into the starting value, which leaves less room for a separate control discount.

## Where does the starting value come from?

Pre-IPO stock is typically valued from one of three reference points, and each starts in a different place:

1. **Preferred round price.** The price per share the lead investor paid in the most recent round. Preferred stock carries liquidation preferences and other rights, so the preferred price is not the value of common.
2. **409A valuation.** An independent appraisal of common stock prepared to price employee options. Treasury Regulation 1.409A-1 gives a presumption of reasonableness to an independent appraisal dated no more than 12 months before the transaction. A 409A report already reflects the gap between preferred and common, so it is a useful starting point, but it is prepared for option pricing, not for a specific gift.
3. **Appraisal for the transfer.** A valuation prepared for the gift or estate event itself. The appraiser considers the round price, the 409A, financial results, market comparables and the specific shares transferred, then applies control and marketability discounts as the facts support.

For an estate, the value is fixed as of the date of death or the alternate valuation date. For a gift, the value is fixed as of the date of the gift. An appraisal prepared months earlier may not reflect a later financing or tender offer.

## What does the IRS require to document a discount?

For a gift, the key requirement is adequate disclosure on Form 709. Treasury Regulation 301.6501(c)-1(f) lists what a return must contain to count as adequately disclosed, including a description of any discounts claimed, such as discounts for minority interests and lack of marketability. A donor can instead attach an appraisal that meets the regulation's standards, prepared by an individual who holds himself or herself out to the public as an appraiser or performs appraisals regularly, and who is qualified to value that type of property.

Adequate disclosure matters because of the statute of limitations. Under IRC Section 6501, the IRS can generally assess additional gift tax only within three years after the return is filed, but a gift that is not adequately shown on a return can be assessed at any time. A well-documented appraisal therefore closes the door on later challenges after three years.

A credible appraisal for a discount on private stock typically:

- Describes the shares, the capitalization table and every transfer restriction.
- States the valuation date and the methods used.
- Explains the empirical support for each discount, such as restricted stock studies or pre-IPO studies.
- Ties each discount to the company's own facts.

Estate returns on Form 706 rely on the same kind of support for illiquid holdings. The charitable "qualified appraisal" rules in Treasury Regulation 1.170A-17 apply to charitable deductions, not to ordinary gifts to family or trusts.

## How does the IRS challenge a discount?

The IRS reviews discounts against the facts of each company, and its valuation staff use an internal Discount for Lack of Marketability Job Aid. That job aid notes that it is not an official IRS position. It surveys benchmark approaches such as restricted stock studies and pre-IPO studies, and it discusses the factors set out by the Tax Court in Mandelbaum v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo 1995-255.

Challenges tend to focus on a few patterns:

- A marketability discount that ignores a near-term liquidity event, such as a signed merger, a filed registration statement or a scheduled tender offer.
- A control discount that overlooks rights the transferred shares actually carry.
- Discounts taken from averages in studies without explaining why the company resembles the studied companies.
- Thin documentation that does not connect the conclusion to the evidence.

In a dispute, the taxpayer generally carries the burden of proof. IRC Section 7491 shifts the burden to the IRS only when the taxpayer introduces credible evidence and meets other conditions, such as maintaining records and cooperating with reasonable IRS requests. In valuation cases, the appraisal is the central piece of that evidence.

## What factors raise or lower the marketability discount?

The marketability discount reflects how hard it would be for a buyer to turn the shares into cash and how long that would take. The Mandelbaum factors summarized in the IRS job aid include the company's financial statements, dividend policy, the nature and outlook of the company, its management, the amount of control in the transferred shares, restrictions on transfer, the expected holding period, the company's redemption policy, and the costs of a public offering.

For venture-backed common stock, those factors usually come down to:

- **Time to liquidity.** A company that has filed for an IPO or signed a merger agreement offers a nearer path to cash, which supports a smaller discount than a company years from an exit.
- **Transfer restrictions.** Rights of first refusal, board consent requirements and lockups support a larger discount.
- **Distributions.** Private venture-backed companies rarely pay dividends, which removes an interim source of return.
- **Secondary activity.** Company-run tender offers or approved secondary sales give holders a partial path to cash and weaken the case for a large discount.
- **Company size and stage.** Larger, later-stage companies with predictable financials usually support smaller discounts.

## What factors raise or lower the control discount?

The control discount reflects what the transferred shares cannot do relative to a controlling block. For common stock in a company where preferred holders and the board hold most of the decision rights, the relevant facts include:

- **Voting rights.** Non-voting common supports a larger discount than voting common.
- **Preferred overhang.** A large stack of senior preferred with liquidation preferences reduces what common holders receive in many exit scenarios.
- **Distribution and redemption rights.** Preferred rights to force redemptions or distributions shift value away from common.
- **Board composition.** A board seat held by the common holder or a related party can reduce the discount.
- **Protective provisions.** Preferred veto rights over sales, financings and new share issuance increase the discount on common.

A founder gifting a small slice of a large personal stake should expect questions about whether the gifted shares, viewed alone, really lack the influence the founder holds overall. Gift tax values the shares actually transferred, but appraisers and the IRS both look at the surrounding facts.

## Why does timing before an IPO matter?

Discounts shrink as a liquidity event becomes more certain. Once a company files its registration statement, buyers can see a path to a public market price within months, so a large marketability discount becomes hard to support. After the IPO, the public trading price becomes the starting point and only restrictions that remain, such as a lockup, support any discount.

| Company stage at the gift date | Control discount pressure | Marketability discount pressure |
|---|---|---|
| Early stage, no exit in view | Highest | Highest |
| Late stage, no filing | High | Moderate to high |
| Registration statement filed | Moderate | Lower |
| Public, inside a lockup | Little or none | Low, tied to the lockup |
| Public, freely tradable | None for a small block | Little or none |

This is why many estate plans for founders transfer shares well before an IPO filing. A transfer made early uses less of the exclusion per share, and the appreciation between the transfer date and the IPO happens outside the estate. A transfer made after a filing uses more exclusion per share and carries a higher risk of challenge if a large discount is claimed.

## How do discounts work with trusts and other gifting structures?

Valuation discounts apply to most transfers of pre-IPO stock, because each one needs a gift or estate tax value:

- **Gifts to irrevocable trusts.** A smaller appraised value uses less of the $15 million 2026 basic exclusion.
- **Grantor retained annuity trusts.** The annuity is set from the appraised value at funding, so the discount affects the annuity payments and the remainder.
- **Installment sales to grantor trusts.** The sale price, and therefore the note, follows the appraised value.
- **Charitable gifts.** A charitable deduction for private stock is generally limited to appraised value and requires a qualified appraisal under the charitable rules.

As arithmetic, a gift reported at $5 million after a 40% combined discount corresponds to about $8.33 million of undiscounted value ($5 million divided by 0.6). The gift moves about 67% more value than the exclusion it uses, provided the discount holds up if examined.

The same discount can work against a family at death. Stock that stays in the estate is valued with the same principles, and a lower estate value also means a lower stepped-up basis for heirs under IRC Section 1014. Families weigh the gift tax saving against the step-up that gifted shares give up.

## What makes discount documentation hold up?

Families that defend discounts successfully tend to share several habits:

1. Engaging a credentialed business appraiser well before the planned transfer date, not after it.
2. Giving the appraiser complete financial statements, the capitalization table, the charter and every agreement that restricts transfer.
3. Having estate counsel review the appraisal's methods and conclusions before the gift is made.
4. Filing a Form 709 that adequately discloses the transfer, including the discounts claimed or a full appraisal, so the three-year assessment period starts running.
5. Keeping the appraisal, board approvals and transfer documents in one file for any later IRS review.
6. Considering a second opinion for very large transfers, where the stakes justify the cost.

For gifts made in 2026, annual exclusion gifts of up to $19,000 per recipient do not use the lifetime exclusion, but a gift of private stock above that amount still needs a return and a defensible value.

## Questions people ask next

### Can valuation discounts apply to stock after the IPO?

Yes, but they are usually much smaller. Once shares trade publicly, the market price is the starting point, and a control discount rarely applies to a small holding. Restrictions that remain, such as a lockup or Rule 144 limits on insider sales, can still support a modest marketability discount, and very large blocks are sometimes valued with a blockage discount. The appraiser has to tie each discount to the specific restriction.

### Can preferred stock be discounted too?

Preferred stock can carry discounts for lack of control and lack of marketability when the holder cannot direct the company and cannot sell freely. The discounts on preferred are usually smaller than on common because preferred holders have liquidation preferences, protective provisions and often board seats. An appraiser values the preferred and common classes separately, and Treasury Regulation 301.6501(c)-1(f) expects the gift return to describe any discounts claimed.

### Does an upcoming tender offer reduce the marketability discount?

Usually. A tender offer or other near-term liquidity event gives holders a realistic path to cash, which weakens the case for a large marketability discount. Appraisers look at whether the gifted shares could actually participate, the price offered, and how much of each holder's position the company allowed to be sold. A known event shortly after the gift date is hard to ignore in a willing buyer, willing seller analysis.

### Can one appraisal support several gifts on different dates?

Gift tax value is measured on the date of each gift, so an appraisal speaks to its own valuation date. A gift made weeks later can rely on the same work only if nothing material changed, such as a new financing round, a tender offer or an IPO filing. Many families refresh the appraisal or obtain a bring-down letter for later gifts, especially when the company is moving toward liquidity.

### Who has to prove the discount is right if the IRS challenges it?

The taxpayer generally carries the burden of proof in a tax dispute. Under IRC Section 7491 the burden can shift to the IRS only if the taxpayer introduces credible evidence and meets conditions such as keeping records and cooperating with reasonable requests. A detailed appraisal by a qualified appraiser is the main credible evidence in a valuation case, which is why the quality of the appraisal matters so much.

## Sources

1. [Rev. Proc. 2025-32](https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rp-25-32.pdf)
   > Section 70106 of the OBBBA amends § 2010(c)(3) by increasing the basic exclusion amount to $15,000,000 for calendar year 2026.
2. [26 CFR 25.2512-1 (Valuation of property; in general)](https://www.ecfr.gov/api/renderer/v1/content/enhanced/current/title-26?part=25&section=25.2512-1)
   > The value of the property is the price at which such property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither being under any compulsion to buy or to sell
3. [26 CFR 301.6501(c)-1(f) (adequate disclosure of gifts)](https://www.ecfr.gov/api/renderer/v1/content/enhanced/current/title-26?part=301&section=301.6501(c)-1)
   > a description of any discounts, such as discounts for blockage, minority or fractional interests, and lack of marketability, claimed in valuing the property
4. [26 U.S.C. § 6501(c)(9) (gifts not shown on return)](https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/t26/s6501)
   > is required to be shown on a return of tax imposed by chapter 12 (without regard to section 2503(b)), and is not shown on such return, any tax imposed by chapter 12 on such gift may be assessed
5. [26 U.S.C. § 7491(a)(2) (Burden of proof, limitations)](https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/t26/s7491)
   > the taxpayer has maintained all records required under this title and has cooperated with reasonable requests by the Secretary for witnesses, information, documents, meetings, and interviews
6. [IRS, Discount for Lack of Marketability Job Aid for IRS Valuation Professionals](https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-lbi/dlom.pdf)
   > The Mandelbaum Factors were set out in Mandelbaum v. Comm., TC Memo 1995-255 (1995), with the opinion written by Judge Laro.
7. [26 CFR 1.409A-1 (Section 409A definitions, valuation presumption)](https://www.ecfr.gov/api/renderer/v1/content/enhanced/current/title-26?part=1&section=1.409A-1)
   > A valuation of a class of stock determined by an independent appraisal that meets the requirements of section 401(a)(28)(C) and the regulations as of a date that is no more than 12 months before the relevant transaction
