# Direct Indexing as a Concentration Offset: Harvesting Losses Against Employer-Stock Gains

URL: https://vestedgrant.com/investing/direct-indexing-concentration-offset
Updated 2026-11-21 · Facts checked 2026-11-21 · Tax year 2026

A direct-indexing account produces a stream of realized losses that can offset employer-stock gains over several years, turning diversification into a tax-aware glide path. How the offset works, what limits it, and how fees and state taxes change the break-even.

## Answer

A direct-indexing account owns an index's stocks individually and sells those that fall below cost, producing realized capital losses even when the index rises. Those losses offset gains from selling employer stock, so a holder can sell concentrated shares at roughly the pace the account produces losses. For 2026, every $60,000 of loss used against long-term gain saves $14,280 at the 23.8% top federal rate, before any state tax.

## Key takeaways

- Selling $3.1 million of long-term gain in one year would cost about $737,800 of federal tax at the 2026 top rate of 23.8%.
- Realized losses offset realized gains in the same year, and up to $3,000 of net loss a year offsets ordinary income; unused losses carry forward with no time limit.
- The wash-sale rule disallows a loss if substantially identical stock is bought within 30 days before or after the sale, including in an IRA or Roth IRA.
- State tax changes the value of each harvested dollar: California taxes capital gains as ordinary income at up to 13.3% (2026), Florida and Texas have no personal income tax, and Washington taxes long-term gains above a $290,000 deduction for 2026.
- Harvesting lowers the basis of the indexed holdings, so the saving is mostly deferral unless those holdings are later donated or held until death.

Consider a hypothetical employee of a company that went public several years ago. She holds $4.2 million of employer stock with $3.1 million of embedded long-term gain. Selling it all in 2026 would produce about $737,800 of federal tax at the 23.8% top rate (20% plus the 3.8% net investment income tax), plus any state tax. Selling over five years spreads the tax, but every year of delay is another year of concentration.

Direct indexing offers a third path. She moves $2 million of existing diversified assets into a separately managed account that tracks a broad index by owning the individual stocks. Over time, individual holdings fall below their purchase price even when the index rises, and the account sells those holdings to realize losses. The amount varies with the market and with the account's age.

The realized losses go on Schedule D against her employer-stock gains. She can then sell employer stock at a pace matched to the losses the account produces, diversifying the concentrated position with less tax each year.

## How does direct indexing produce losses when the index is flat or up?

An index is an average of hundreds of stocks. Even in a year when the index rises, a meaningful share of its individual stocks will trade below the price at which an account bought them at some point during the year. A direct-indexing account that owns those stocks individually can sell the ones below cost to realize losses while holding the others.

The account is not trying to beat the index. It is trying to stay close to the index's return after fees while realizing as many losses as practical. When a holding falls a set amount below its cost, the manager sells it and buys a similar replacement, often a different company in the same industry or a fund covering the sector. After the wash-sale window passes, the manager either buys back the original holding or keeps the replacement, depending on how far the portfolio has drifted from the index.

The replacement step matters. Under IRC Section 1091, a loss is disallowed if substantially identical stock is acquired within 30 days before or after the sale. IRS Publication 550 says stock of one corporation is ordinarily not substantially identical to stock of another, which is why swapping between similar companies preserves the loss.

## What loss yield can be expected, and how does it change?

The share of an account harvested as losses each year depends on the market. Losses are scarcer in strong, steady rising markets and more plentiful in flat, falling or volatile ones. Provider projections differ and past results do not predict future ones, so planning usually uses ranges rather than a single number.

Loss yield also declines as an account ages. A new account funded with cash has many holdings near their purchase price, so small declines create harvesting opportunities. A five-year-old account in a rising market has many holdings well above cost, so fewer are available to harvest. New cash contributions and market declines renew the supply.

For a concentrated-stock offset, this pattern matters. The loss engine is usually strongest in the first years after funding, then tapers. Plans that sell the concentrated position over several years often match the pace of sales to the expected loss production, selling more employer stock in the early years when harvested losses are more plentiful.

## How do harvested losses offset employer-stock gains?

Gains and losses are first sorted into short-term and long-term. Long-term losses from the indexed account offset long-term gains on employer stock, and short-term losses offset short-term gains. Any net loss left in one category then offsets net gain in the other.

As a simple illustration: realize $90,000 of long-term losses in the indexed account and $90,000 of long-term gain on employer stock in the same year, and the net capital gain for the year is zero. The wash-sale rule is not an issue for this offset because the losses come from sales of other companies' stock and the gain comes from employer stock, as long as no employer stock is repurchased within 30 days of a loss sale of employer shares.

Losses that exceed gains are not wasted. Up to $3,000 of net capital loss a year offsets ordinary income, and the rest carries forward to later years under IRC Section 1212, with no expiration for individuals. When the strategy is working, sales of employer stock are usually sized so the account rarely has large unused losses.

## How does direct indexing compare with funds for this purpose?

| Vehicle | Realized losses available to the investor | Transparency | Relative cost | Offset against employer-stock gains |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Direct-indexing account | Yes, on each holding | Full, holding by holding | Highest of the indexed options | Direct, each year |
| Broad-market ETF | Only on sale of the ETF itself | Fund level | Lowest | Only if the ETF is sold at a loss |
| Actively managed mutual fund | Only on sale of the fund; may distribute gains | Fund level | Varies, often higher than an ETF | No, and gain distributions can add to the tax |
| Individual stock picking | Yes | Full | Trading costs and time | Possible but irregular |

The structural difference is that fund investors cannot realize losses on the fund's internal holdings; they can only realize a gain or loss on the fund shares themselves. Direct indexing opens up the wrapper and makes every holding its own tax lot.

## What is the break-even after fees and state tax?

Direct indexing costs more each year than a low-cost index fund. Whether the harvested losses cover that cost depends on how much is harvested and on the tax rate of the gains being offset. As an illustration, assume a $2 million account harvests $60,000 of losses in a year and costs 0.30% a year more than an index fund, or $6,000.

| Holder (hypothetical) | Rate on offset long-term gains | Tax saved on $60,000 | Net of $6,000 extra fee |
|---|---|---|---|
| California resident | 37.1% (23.8% federal plus 13.3% state, 2026 top rate) | $22,260 | $16,260, about 0.8% of the account |
| Florida or Texas resident | 23.8% federal only | $14,280 | $8,280, about 0.4% |
| Washington resident with gains above the state deduction | 30.8% (23.8% federal plus 7% state) | $18,480 | $12,480, about 0.6% |

Florida and Texas do not levy a personal income tax. Washington has no wage income tax but imposes a 7% tax on long-term capital gains above a $290,000 standard deduction for 2026, with an additional 2.9% on gains above $1 million, so it is not a zero-tax state for large stock sales.

The strategy is most valuable for holders in high-tax states with large embedded gains and enough other assets to fund a meaningful indexed account.

## What are the main risks and failure modes?

**Tracking difference.** A direct-indexed account does not match its index exactly. Over long periods the difference is usually small, but in a given year the account can trail or lead the index by a noticeable margin, especially when stocks are excluded.

**Tax-time complexity.** Every sale is a separate tax lot, and an active account can produce many transactions a year. The manager provides a Form 1099-B with supporting detail, but the tax preparer needs to handle the volume and the wash-sale adjustments.

**Loss exhaustion.** After several years in a rising market, most holdings sit well above cost and few losses remain to harvest. At that point the account is essentially a low-basis index portfolio. Some investors then move to an index fund for lower fees, donate the lowest-basis lots to charity, or keep the account for a later step-up in basis at death under IRC Section 1014.

**Cross-account wash sales.** If the investor owns the same stocks in another account, including an IRA, purchases there can disallow losses harvested in the indexed account. Rev. Rul. 2008-5 applies the wash-sale rule to IRA and Roth IRA purchases. Managers typically ask for a list of outside holdings and restrict those stocks.

## What does an offset plan need before the first sale?

An offset plan starts with a schedule of how much employer-stock gain the holder intends to realize in each of the next three to five years, the holder's federal and state rates on that gain, and the size of the account that will produce the offsetting losses. A provider's historical loss-yield analysis for an account of that size gives a range rather than a promise. Funding the indexed account some weeks before the first employer-stock sale gives it time to own positions that can be harvested, and an inventory of every account that holds or buys the same stocks keeps the wash-sale rule from erasing the losses.

## Questions people ask next

### Can a direct-indexing account be opened inside an IRA?

A direct-indexing account can be held in an IRA, but harvesting losses there has no tax value, because gains and losses inside an IRA are not reported on the owner's return. Purchases inside an IRA can still disallow losses in taxable accounts under the wash-sale rule, as Rev. Rul. 2008-5 confirms. Loss harvesting is a strategy for taxable accounts.

### How large does a direct-indexing account need to be?

Minimums vary by provider, and many retail-oriented programs now accept accounts in the low six figures, while some premium managers require more. The more useful test is whether expected harvested losses, multiplied by the holder's tax rate on the gains they offset, exceed the extra fee over an index fund. That test favors larger accounts, high-tax states and holders with steady gains to offset.

### Can employer stock be used to fund a direct-indexing account?

Some managers accept a concentrated position as part of the account and build a diversified portfolio around it, often called a completion or transition portfolio. The manager then sells the concentrated stock gradually, timing sales to match losses harvested elsewhere in the account. The employer's stock is usually excluded from new purchases so the account does not add to the concentration or create wash sales.

### Do harvested losses offset short-term gains from recently vested RSUs?

Harvested losses offset short-term gains as well as long-term gains. Losses are first netted within their own category, short-term against short-term and long-term against long-term, and any net loss in one category then offsets net gain in the other. Because short-term gains are taxed at ordinary rates, a loss that ends up offsetting short-term gain saves more tax per dollar than one that offsets long-term gain.

### How long does a direct-indexing offset plan usually run?

Planners commonly frame these programs over several years, because the account needs time to produce losses and the concentrated position is usually too large to sell in one year without high tax. Harvesting tends to be strongest in the first years after funding, so many plans front-load the sales. The break-even depends on fees, market conditions and the holder's tax rates.

## Sources

1. [IRS Topic no. 409, Capital gains and losses](https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc409)
   > the amount of the excess loss that you can claim to lower your income is the lesser of $3,000 ($1,500 if married filing separately)
2. [Rev. Proc. 2025-32](https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rp-25-32.pdf)
   > Heads of Household $66,200 $579,600 All Other Individuals $49,450 $545,500
3. [IRS Topic no. 559, Net investment income tax](https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc559)
   > A 3.8 percent net investment income tax (NIIT) applies to individuals, estates, and trusts that have net investment income above applicable threshold amounts.
4. [FTB Tax News October 2026 - 2026 Indexing](https://www.ftb.ca.gov/about-ftb/newsroom/tax-news/2026/10.html)
   > 460,927 768,213 39,951.95 + 11.30% of the amount over 460,927 768,213 & OVER 74,675.27 + 12.30% of the amount over 768,213
5. [FTB 2025 Form 540 Booklet, Schedule CA line 7a](https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/2025/2025-540-booklet.pdf)
   > California taxes long and short term capital gains as regular income. No special rate for long term capital gains exists.
6. [FTB 2025 Schedule P (540)](https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/2025/2025-540-p.pdf)
   > 24 Tentative Minimum Tax. Multiply line 23 by 7.0% (.07)
7. [California Employer's Guide 2026 (DE 44 Rev. 52)](https://edd.ca.gov/siteassets/files/pdf_pub_ctr/de44.pdf)
   > Supplemental Wages Percentage Bonuses and stock options 10.23 percent (.1023) Other types (such as overtime pay, commissions, sales awards, severance, and vacation pay) 6.6 percent (.066)
8. [FTB 2025 Instructions for Schedule D (540), California Capital Gain or Loss Adjustment](https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/2025/2025-540-d-instructions.html)
   > Qualified Small Business Stock – California does not conform to the qualified small business stock deferral and gain exclusion under IRC Sections 1045 and 1202. Enter the entire gain realized in column (e).
9. [Fla. Stat. § 220.02 (2026 Florida Statutes, Ch. 220)](https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2026/Chapter220/All)
   > the mandate in s. 5, Art. VII of the State Constitution that no income tax be levied upon natural persons who are residents and citizens of this state.
10. [Florida Department of Revenue FAQ: Do I have to file a personal income tax return in Florida?](https://floridarevenue.com/faq/Pages/FAQDetails.aspx?FAQID=1466)
   > Florida does not impose a personal income tax, so there are no filing requirements.
11. [Texas Constitution Art. VIII, Sec. 24-a (Texas Legislative Council PDF)](https://tlc.texas.gov/docs/legref/TxConst.pdf)
   > Sec. 24‑a. INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX PROHIBITED. The legislature may not impose a tax on the net incomes of individuals, including an individual’s share of partnership and unincorporated association income.
12. [Texas Comptroller, Fiscal Notes: Starting a New Business (Feb 2016)](https://comptroller.texas.gov/economy/fiscal-notes/archive/2016/february/starting.php)
   > Texas does not have a personal income tax, and sole proprietorships, the state's most common form of new business, are completely exempt from the franchise tax
13. [WA DOR - Income tax](https://dor.wa.gov/taxes-rates/income-tax)
   > Washington does not currently have an individual income tax. Beginning Jan. 1, 2028, a new 9.9% income tax will apply to individuals and married couples filing jointly with annual adjusted gross income exceeding $1 million.
14. [WA DOR special notice - New tiered rates for Washington's capital gains tax](https://dor.wa.gov/forms-publications/publications-subject/special-notices/new-tiered-rates-washingtons-capital-gains-tax)
   > Your first $1 million in taxable Washington capital gains is subject to tax at a rate of 7%. Any amount of Washington capital gains exceeding $1 million is subject to a 7% tax, plus an additional 2.9% tax.
15. [WA DOR - Do you owe capital gains tax? (Updated Amounts table)](https://dor.wa.gov/taxes-rates/other-taxes/capital-gains-tax/do-you-owe-capital-gains-tax)
   > Tax Year 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 Standard Deduction 250,000 262,000 270,000 278,000 290,000
16. [RCW 82.87.040 Tax imposed](https://app.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=82.87.040)
   > which equals 2.90 percent multiplied by the portion of an individual's Washington capital gains exceeding $1,000,000.
17. [RCW 82.87.150 Annual adjustments (indexes standard deduction, not the $1M tier)](https://app.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=82.87.150)
   > "Applicable amounts" means: (i) The distribution amount to the education legacy trust account as provided in RCW 82.87.030 (1)(a); (ii) The standard deduction amount in RCW 82.87.020 (16) and 82.87.060 (1);
18. [Washington Department of Revenue: Income tax](https://dor.wa.gov/node/723)
   > Washington does not currently have an individual income tax. Beginning Jan. 1, 2028, a new 9.9% income tax will apply to individuals and married couples filing jointly
19. [WA Paid Leave 2026 paycheck insert (ESD, updated December 2025)](https://paidleave.wa.gov/app/uploads/2025/12/Paycheck-insert-2026-1.pdf)
   > The total premium rate is 1.13% of gross wages, up to the social security cap of $184,500.
20. [WA Cares Fund: Employer Information](https://wacaresfund.wa.gov/employers)
   > The premium is 0.58% of an employee's gross wages ... Note that unlike Paid Leave, premium contributions are not capped at the taxable maximum for social security.
21. [Washington DOR, Frequently asked questions about Washington's capital gains tax](https://dor.wa.gov/taxes-rates/other-taxes/capital-gains-tax/frequently-asked-questions-about-washingtons-capital-gains-tax)
   > No, you do not owe Washington's capital gains tax on gain from the sale or exchange of qualified small business stock if the gain was excluded from your federal net long-term capital gain under IRC Section 1202.
22. [FTB 2026 Instructions for Form 540-ES, Behavioral Health Services Tax](https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/2026/2026-540-es-instructions.html)
   > Less: $(1,000,000) Subtotal Tax rate – 1%: × .01 Behavioral Health Services Tax
23. [26 U.S.C. § 1091 (Loss from wash sales of stock or securities)](https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/t26/s1091)
   > within a period beginning 30 days before the date of such sale or disposition and ending 30 days after such date, the taxpayer has acquired
24. [IRS Rev. Rul. 2008-5 (Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-3)](https://www.irs.gov/irb/2008-03_IRB)
   > if an individual sells stock or securities for a loss and causes his or her IRA or Roth IRA to purchase substantially identical stock or securities within a specified period
25. [IRS Publication 550, Investment Income and Expenses (substantially identical)](https://www.irs.gov/publications/p550)
   > Ordinarily, stocks or securities of one corporation are not considered substantially identical to stocks or securities of another corporation.
26. [26 U.S.C. § 1212 (Capital loss carrybacks and carryovers)](https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/t26/s1212)
   > the excess of the net long-term capital loss over the net short-term capital gain for such year shall be a long-term capital loss in the succeeding taxable year
27. [26 U.S.C. § 1014 (Basis of property acquired from a decedent)](https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/t26/s1014)
   > the fair market value of the property at the date of the decedent’s death
