VestedGrant
Find an advisor

Case study · Engineer at OpenAI holding PPUs

OpenAI PPU Holder: Planning Around Tax Uncertainty

  • PPU
  • profit participation unit
  • non-standard equity
  • California
  • pre-ipo
  • $1-3M

An engineer who sells $168,000 of profit-participation-style units in a 2026 tender and has 22% federal withholding taken can plan for ordinary wage treatment, about $23,300 more federal tax at the 35% and 37% brackets, and keep a reserve for the worst case: if the payment were deferred compensation that failed Section 409A, a 20% additional tax plus interest would apply, about $33,600 on $168,000.

Facts checked November 21, 2026 · Figures for tax year 2026

Key takeaways

  1. Compensation paid under a plan that fails Section 409A is taxed when vested and also carries an additional tax equal to 20% of the amount plus interest.
  2. A payment is a short-term deferral outside Section 409A if it is received by the 15th day of the third month after the end of the year in which it vests.
  3. Withholding at the 22% supplemental rate leaves a gap for an employee whose income reaches the 35% or 37% brackets for 2026.
  4. Form 8275 lets a taxpayer disclose a return position that is not otherwise adequately disclosed, to avoid certain penalties.
  5. Only stock in a C corporation can be qualified small business stock, so a contractual profit unit does not qualify for the Section 1202 exclusion.

This case is a composite: the engineer, his units, their terms and every price are illustrative, built from patterns common to employees holding profit-participation-style awards at private AI labs. OpenAI is still a private company as of November 2026, and nothing here describes its actual award terms, tender prices or corporate structure. Consider an engineer who joined in 2023 and received units that entitle him to a share of the company’s future profits rather than shares of stock. A 2026 tender lets him sell some of them. His question is how to plan for a tax bill whose character is not settled.

What are the units in this composite?

The units in this composite are a contractual right to a share of profit distributions, with no strike price and no shares behind them. In this composite:

  • 300 units vesting over four years, with a one-year cliff and quarterly vesting after it.
  • Each unit entitles him to a share of profit distributions once investors’ returns reach their caps.
  • The company runs periodic tenders for employees with minimum tenure.

Because the units are not stock, the usual rules for RSUs and options do not map onto them cleanly, and the right characterization depends on documents and facts outside this composite.

Which tax treatments are possible?

Three tax treatments were considered, each with a different result:

  1. Compensation in the form of property under Section 83. The Section 83 regulations exclude an unfunded and unsecured promise to pay money or property in the future from the definition of property, so a bare contractual promise is usually not property until it is paid. Payment is then ordinary wage income.
  2. Deferred compensation under Section 409A. If the units are a deferred compensation plan, payments are ordinary income, and a plan that fails Section 409A’s timing rules makes the vested amount taxable with an additional tax equal to 20% of it plus interest. A payment made by the 15th day of the third month after the end of the year in which it vests is a short-term deferral outside Section 409A.
  3. Investment-style treatment. Capital gain treatment would require the units to be a capital interest the holder owns, which the terms of a compensatory profit unit may not support.

The planning question is not which treatment is right, but how much cash to hold until it is settled.

What did the 2026 tender look like?

The 2026 tender in this composite paid an assumed $4,200 a unit. He had 120 vested units and sold 40, $168,000 of proceeds. The company reported the payment as wages and withheld 22% federal, $36,960, plus California’s 10.23% supplemental rate, about $17,186, and California SDI of 1.3%, about $2,184.

TreatmentFederal tax on $168,000Planning response
Ordinary wages, Section 83 or compliant Section 409Aabout $60,226Pay the gap of about $23,266 beyond withholding
Section 409A failureabout $60,226 plus $33,600 additional tax plus interestKeep a reserve
Capital gainat most 20% plus 3.8% NIITNo reliance without a written opinion

He is single with $560,000 of other wages in 2026, so the units take his taxable income from $543,900 to $711,900. The first $96,700 is taxed at 35% and the remaining $71,300 at 37%, about $60,226 in all.

What did he do?

He treated the $168,000 as ordinary wages, which matched how the company reported it, and made a fourth-quarter estimated payment of about $23,300 for the federal gap, due January 15, 2027. He kept a separate reserve of $33,600, equal to the 20% additional tax under Section 409A, until the treatment was clearer.

He also had a tax lawyer review the plan documents for Section 409A. A payment made within the short-term deferral period, by March 15 of the year after the year a unit vests for a calendar-year taxpayer, falls outside Section 409A. In this composite the lawyer concluded the tender payments were not deferred compensation of the kind Section 409A penalizes, which made the worst case less likely without ruling it out.

For later tranches he plans to keep selling in tenders as cash needs allow, and to report the proceeds as wages unless clearer guidance changes that.

What would he change in hindsight?

In hindsight he would have asked about Form 8275 when filing. Taxpayers use Form 8275 to disclose items or positions not otherwise adequately disclosed on a return, to avoid certain penalties. For an unsettled item, disclosure is a low-cost way to show the position he took.

He would also track each vesting date against the short-term deferral deadline. A payment made after the 15th day of the third month following the year of vesting falls outside the exception, so a tender that slips past that date changes the analysis.

Frequently asked

Why might an AI lab use profit units instead of RSUs or options?

An AI lab might use profit units instead of RSUs or options when its legal structure does not issue ordinary common stock to employees, or when it wants employee payouts tied to profit distributions. The tax result then depends on the contract rather than on the familiar stock rules, so the award documents and the company’s tax reporting carry more weight than usual.

Is there IRS guidance specific to profit participation units?

No IRS guidance addresses profit participation units of this kind by name, so their treatment follows the general rules for compensation: Section 83 for transfers of property, Section 409A for deferred compensation, and the wage rules for payments reported on Form W-2. A holder relies on the company’s reporting and, for unusual positions, on written advice and disclosure.

Can tender proceeds from profit units be treated as capital gain?

Tender proceeds from compensatory profit units are generally reported as wages when the company treats them that way, and a holder taking a capital gain position instead would be contradicting the company’s reporting. That position would need a written opinion and, for an unsettled item, disclosure on Form 8275 to avoid certain penalties.

What happens to unvested units on leaving the company?

Unvested units are usually forfeited on leaving the company under standard vesting terms, and vested but unpaid units follow whatever the plan says about former employees, such as eligibility for later tenders. Forfeiting units that were never paid produces no taxable income and no deduction.

Do profit units qualify for QSBS?

Profit units do not qualify for QSBS, because Section 1202 applies only to stock in a C corporation that meets its other tests. A contractual right to a share of profits is not stock, so gains or payments on it cannot be excluded under Section 1202 even if the company itself would otherwise qualify.

Sources

  1. Rev. Proc. 2025-32irs.gov
    Supporting text
    Over $640,600 $192,979.25 plus 37% of the excess over $640,600
  2. IRS Publication 15 (2026), (Circular E), Employer's Tax Guideirs.gov
    Supporting text
    The withholding rate on supplemental wages remains 22% (37% if supplemental wages paid to an employee during the calendar year exceed $1 million) because P.L. 119-21 permanently extended the individual tax rates
  3. IRS Form 1040-ES (2026), Estimated Tax for Individualsirs.gov
    Supporting text
    If your adjusted gross income (AGI) for 2025 was more than $150,000 ($75,000 if your filing status for 2026 is married filing separately), substitute 110% for 100% in (2b) under General Rule
  4. FTB Tax News October 2026 - 2026 Indexingftb.ca.gov
    Supporting text
    460,927 768,213 39,951.95 + 11.30% of the amount over 460,927 768,213 & OVER 74,675.27 + 12.30% of the amount over 768,213
  5. FTB 2025 Form 540 Booklet, Schedule CA line 7aftb.ca.gov
    Supporting text
    California taxes long and short term capital gains as regular income. No special rate for long term capital gains exists.
  6. FTB 2025 Schedule P (540)ftb.ca.gov
    Supporting text
    24 Tentative Minimum Tax. Multiply line 23 by 7.0% (.07)
  7. California Employer's Guide 2026 (DE 44 Rev. 52)edd.ca.gov
    Supporting text
    Supplemental Wages Percentage Bonuses and stock options 10.23 percent (.1023) Other types (such as overtime pay, commissions, sales awards, severance, and vacation pay) 6.6 percent (.066)
  8. FTB 2025 Instructions for Schedule D (540), California Capital Gain or Loss Adjustmentftb.ca.gov
    Supporting text
    Qualified Small Business Stock – California does not conform to the qualified small business stock deferral and gain exclusion under IRC Sections 1045 and 1202. Enter the entire gain realized in column (e).
Show 5 more sources
  1. 26 U.S.C. § 409A(a)(1)(B), Interest and additional taxuscode.house.gov
    Supporting text
    the tax imposed by this chapter for the taxable year shall be increased by the sum of (I) the amount of interest determined under clause (ii), and (II) an amount equal to 20 percent of the compensation
  2. 26 CFR § 1.409A-1(b)(4), Short-term deferralsecfr.gov
    Supporting text
    The applicable 2 1 ⁄ 2 month period is the period ending on the later of the 15th day of the third month following the end of the service provider's first taxable year in which the right to the payment is no longer subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture
  3. 26 CFR § 1.83-3(e), Meaning and use of certain terms: propertyecfr.gov
    Supporting text
    the term "property" includes real and personal property other than either money or an unfunded and unsecured promise to pay money or property in the future.
  4. IRS, About Form 8275, Disclosure Statementirs.gov
    Supporting text
    Taxpayers and tax return preparers use this form to disclose items or positions that are not otherwise adequately disclosed on a tax return to avoid certain penalties.
  5. 26 U.S.C. § 1202(c)(1), Qualified small business stockuscode.house.gov
    Supporting text
    the term "qualified small business stock" means any stock in a C corporation which is originally issued after the date of the enactment of the Revenue Reconciliation Act of 1993

Facts checked November 21, 2026 · Tax year 2026

Find a fee-only advisor for your equity

Four questions. You see up to three fee-only advisors listed on Wellspent whose records include equity compensation, right here. Free, no obligation.

  • What happens next: your matches appear on this page straight away. Advisors are not sent your details: you open a record and contact the advisor yourself.
  • What is shared: your email stays with VestedGrant and is not passed to advisors. The advisor directory (Wellspent) receives your state and topic; an AI model ranks the matches from your answers, without your email. Details in the privacy policy.
Find a fee-only advisor