VestedGrant
Find an advisor

10b5-1 Plan Structures: Fixed-Share, Fixed-Dollar, and Limit-Price

By VestedGrant Editorial · Updated · Tax year 2026 · 6 min read

Homer Dodge Martin, On the Seine, c. 1895

The three common 10b5-1 plan structures are fixed-share (sell a set number of shares on each date), fixed-dollar (sell a set dollar value) and limit-price (sell only at or above a set price). Rule 10b5-1 allows each because it defines amount as shares or dollar value and price as market, limit or dollar price. In a hypothetical 12-month path, they raised $1,600,000, $1,560,000 and $734,000.

Facts checked November 21, 2026 · Figures for tax year 2026 · 1 sources

Key takeaways

  1. Rule 10b5-1 defines amount as either a number of shares or a dollar value, and price as the market price on a date, a limit price or a particular dollar price, so all three structures fit the rule.
  2. In a hypothetical 12-month price path averaging $66.67, selling 2,000 shares a month raised $1,600,000, while selling $130,000 a month raised $1,560,000 from 23,658 shares.
  3. A limit-price layer of 2,000 shares at $70 or more executed in 5 of 12 months in the same example, raising $734,000 at an average of $73.40.
  4. Changing a plan's structure mid-stream is a change to amount, price or timing, which the rule treats as a new plan with a new cooling-off period of 90 to 120 days for officers and directors in 2026.

When an executive adopts a 10b5-1 plan, the trading formula inside it decides what happens on each execution date. The three most common structures are fixed-share, fixed-dollar and limit-price. Each reacts differently when the price moves, produces different proceeds from the same price path and draws different kinds of criticism when the stock moves unexpectedly.

Rule 10b5-1 accommodates all three. The rule defines “amount” as either a number of shares or a dollar value, and “price” as the market price on a date, a limit price or a particular dollar price. This article covers each structure, combinations of them, a worked comparison and the terms a plan should fix.

How does a fixed-share 10b5-1 plan work?

A fixed-share plan sells a set number of shares on each execution date. A hypothetical plan might sell 2,000 shares on the 15th of each month for 12 months, 24,000 shares in total. Proceeds rise and fall with the price: if the stock trades at $50 in the first month and $70 in the last, the last sale raises $40,000 more than the first.

Advantages:

  • Simple to explain and execute
  • Predictable reduction in share count
  • Fits targets set in shares, such as cutting a holding from 100,000 to 80,000 shares

Disadvantages:

  • Cash proceeds vary widely with price
  • In a price spike, the plan sells the same number of shares at high prices, which can look aggressive
  • In a decline, the plan keeps selling at lower prices

Fixed-share plans suit share-count targets and executives who are comfortable with variable cash proceeds.

How does a fixed-dollar 10b5-1 plan work?

A fixed-dollar plan sells a set dollar value on each date, and the broker works out the share count from the price. A hypothetical plan might sell $500,000 of stock on the 15th of each month for 12 months, $6 million in total. When the price falls, more shares are sold to reach $500,000; when it rises, fewer.

Advantages:

  • Steady cash proceeds, which suits planned spending, gifts or tax payments
  • Fewer shares sold as the price climbs, which can read as less aggressive

Disadvantages:

  • In a sharp decline the share count climbs quickly and can exhaust the position
  • The plan needs a clear pricing reference (market, open, close or a limit) for the broker’s share calculation
  • The account must hold enough shares for the worst case

Fixed-dollar plans fit specific cash needs and situations where selling fewer shares at higher prices is the intent. An aggregate share cap and a minimum price, both set at adoption, are the usual protections against a crash.

How does a limit-price 10b5-1 plan work?

A limit-price plan sells only if the stock reaches a set price during a set period. A hypothetical plan might sell 2,000 shares if the stock trades at $75 or more during the second week of each month, with no sale in months when it does not. Rule 10b5-1 treats a limit order as having a “date” on each day it is in force, so a window of days fits the rule.

Advantages:

  • Avoids selling at low prices
  • Captures upside when the stock rises
  • Matches value-sensitive selling discipline

Disadvantages:

  • Timing and proceeds are unpredictable
  • In flat or falling markets the plan may never execute, leaving the full position
  • Limits set too high mean no trades; set too low, they mean sales at prices the insider would not have chosen

Limit-price plans suit executives who want to sell only at set price targets, and they work well as a layer on top of a regular schedule.

How do combination plans layer the structures?

Many executive plans combine the three structures in a single plan:

  • Base layer. A small fixed-share or fixed-dollar sale each period guarantees some execution whatever the market does.
  • Limit layer. Additional sales trigger when the price reaches set levels, capturing upside without selling into weakness.
  • Vesting layer. Sales to cover tax withholding at vesting. Since 2023 a plan limited to such sell-to-cover sales can sit alongside the main plan without counting against the one-plan limit; alternatively the same sales can be written into the main plan.

A hypothetical combined plan:

LayerTerms
BaseSell 1,000 shares on the 15th of each month for 12 months
LimitSell 2,000 more shares in any month the price is $75 or more on the execution date
VestingSell enough shares at each vest to cover withholding

Total sales depend on the price path. The base layer is predictable; the limit layer captures strength. Using the price path in the comparison section below, this plan sells 12,000 base shares for $800,000 and 4,000 limit shares in months 7 and 8 for $310,000, a total of $1,110,000 before vesting sales.

How much discretion can the broker have?

Rule 10b5-1 allows a plan to leave some discretion with the broker, provided the insider has no later influence and anyone exercising discretion is not aware of material nonpublic information. Typical discretion by structure:

StructureDiscretion commonly left to the broker
Fixed-shareTiming within the execution day, for example spreading the order to limit market impact
Fixed-dollarComputing the share count from the plan’s stated pricing reference and executing it
Limit-priceMonitoring the price during the window and executing if the limit is reached

What the broker cannot do is trade outside the plan’s dates, change the share count or dollar amount, or take new instructions from the insider. Any change by the insider to amount, price or timing is a termination and a new plan under Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)(iv).

Which terms should every plan specify?

Whatever the structure, a plan that holds up well specifies:

  • The formula: fixed-share, fixed-dollar, limit-price or a combination
  • Execution dates or windows
  • Share counts or dollar amounts
  • The pricing reference for share calculations (market price, close, a limit)
  • Limit prices and how long each is in force
  • Aggregate caps on shares, dollars and duration
  • Broker authority and contact details
  • Termination events such as death, incapacity or a change in employment
  • How amounts and prices adjust for splits and similar corporate actions
  • The officer or director certification, where required

Plan duration is set by the plan itself. Longer plans need fewer new adoptions and cooling-off periods; shorter plans are easier to replace with a fresh design. Any extension or change to the schedule counts as a new plan.

How do the structures compare on the same price path?

Take a hypothetical 12-month path of execution-day prices: $60, $65, $55, $70, $62, $58, $75, $80, $65, $70, $68, $72, which averages $66.67. Assume each sale fills at that day’s price.

StructureShares soldProceedsAverage price received
Fixed-share: 2,000 shares a month24,000$1,600,000$66.67
Fixed-dollar: $130,000 a month23,658$1,560,000$65.94
Limit-price: 2,000 shares when price is $70 or more10,000 (months 4, 7, 8, 10, 12)$734,000$73.40

The fixed-share plan received the simple average price. The fixed-dollar plan sold more shares at low prices and fewer at high prices, so its average price received, $65.94, was below the simple average. The limit-price plan received the highest average price but sold well under half as many shares and left 14,000 more shares unsold than the fixed-share plan.

None of these is better in general. The comparison shows the trade-off: certainty of execution against price received.

How do you choose a structure?

Match the structure to the goal:

  • Target set in shares: fixed-share.
  • Target set in cash: fixed-dollar, with an aggregate share cap and a minimum price.
  • Target set in price: limit-price, accepting that some or all orders may not fill.

Many executives use a combination: a base layer to make sure some selling happens and a limit layer for strength. Writing down three numbers before talking with a broker helps: total shares to sell, total dollars wanted and any price at or above which more selling is acceptable. Those three numbers map directly onto base and limit layers, and fixing them at adoption avoids later changes that would restart the cooling-off period, which for directors and officers in 2026 is the later of 90 days or two business days after the quarter’s 10-Q or 10-K, capped at 120 days.

Questions people ask next

Which 10b5-1 plan structure draws the least criticism?

No 10b5-1 structure is immune to criticism, but the patterns differ. A fixed-share plan sells the same number of shares into a price spike, which can read as aggressive. A fixed-dollar plan sells fewer shares as the price rises. A limit-price plan sells only at chosen levels, which can look price-driven even though the levels were fixed at adoption.

Can I switch my 10b5-1 plan from fixed-share to fixed-dollar?

Switching a 10b5-1 plan from fixed-share to fixed-dollar changes the amount of each sale, so Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)(iv) treats it as a termination and a new plan. For 2026 the new plan needs a new cooling-off period of 90 to 120 days for directors and officers, or 30 days for others, and a new certification for directors and officers.

What happens if the stock falls sharply during a fixed-dollar 10b5-1 plan?

In a fixed-dollar 10b5-1 plan, a sharp price drop means each sale uses more shares. If the plan has no total share cap, it can sell much more of the position than expected. A plan can include an aggregate share cap or a minimum price below which no sale occurs, set at adoption so that the broker does not need new instructions.

What happens if my 10b5-1 limit price is never reached?

If a 10b5-1 plan's limit price is never reached, those shares are not sold and the orders lapse when the plan ends. That is the plan working as written, not a modification. Selling the shares later requires either a trade in an open window outside the plan or a new plan with its own cooling-off period.

Does a 10b5-1 plan need to say how the broker prices each sale?

A 10b5-1 plan works best when it states the pricing reference, such as market price on the date, a limit price or the closing price, because the rule ties the defense to amount, price and date or a formula for them. Vague terms leave discretion with the broker, which is allowed only if the broker is not aware of material nonpublic information.

Sources

  1. 17 CFR 240.10b5-1 (eCFR)ecfr.gov
    Supporting text
    no purchases or sales occur until expiration of a cooling-off period consisting of the later of: (i) Ninety days after the adoption of the contract, instruction, or plan or

Facts checked November 21, 2026 · Tax year 2026

Find a fee-only advisor for your equity

Four questions. You see up to three fee-only advisors listed on Wellspent whose records include equity compensation, right here. Free, no obligation.

  • What happens next: your matches appear on this page straight away. Advisors are not sent your details: you open a record and contact the advisor yourself.
  • What is shared: your email stays with VestedGrant and is not passed to advisors. The advisor directory (Wellspent) receives your state and topic; an AI model ranks the matches from your answers, without your email. Details in the privacy policy.
Multiple 10b5-1 Plans: The Single-Plan-at-a-Time Rule and Its Exceptions Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)(ii)(D) denies the affirmative defense to a person who holds more than one open-market 10b5-1 plan for any class of the same company's securities, with three exceptions: contracts with several brokers treated as one plan, one later-commencing plan that cannot trade until the first finishes, and a plan that only sells to cover tax withholding at vesting. A separate limit allows one single-trade plan per 12 months. Required 10-Q / 10-K Disclosures Under the 2022 10b5-1 Rules Item 408(a) of Regulation S-K requires a public company to state in each Form 10-Q and Form 10-K whether any director or officer adopted or terminated a Rule 10b5-1 plan or other written trading arrangement during the last fiscal quarter, giving the person's name and title, the date, the plan's duration and the aggregate number of securities. Price terms are left out. Most companies have reported this since fiscal periods beginning on or after April 1, 2023. The 2023 10b5-1 Amendments: 90-Day Cooling-Off and Good-Faith Certification The 2023 amendments to Rule 10b5-1, effective February 27, 2023, require directors and officers to wait the later of 90 days after adopting a plan or two business days after the 10-Q or 10-K for that quarter, capped at 120 days, before the first trade. Everyone else except the issuer waits 30 days. Officers and directors must also certify in the plan that they hold no material nonpublic information. 10b5-1 Plans in an Acquisition Scenario A 10b5-1 plan adopted before a person learned of acquisition talks keeps its affirmative defense for trades made on schedule during those talks, as long as the person does not change or game it. Adopting or changing a plan while aware of the talks forfeits the defense. After a stock-for-stock deal closes, a new plan in acquirer shares needs a fresh cooling-off: 90 to 120 days for officers and directors in 2026.
Find a fee-only advisor