VestedGrant
Find an advisor

Net-Share Settlement vs Sell-to-Cover: Which Withholding Default Costs You Less

By VestedGrant Editorial · Updated · Tax year 2026 · 6 min read

Sanford Robinson Gifford, Cows in a Pond at Sunset, 1860

Net-share settlement and sell-to-cover withhold the same tax on RSU income, at a flat 22% federal rate on supplemental wages for 2026 (37% above $1 million). Net-share settlement keeps back whole shares valued at the vest-date price, so the delivered share count is predictable. Sell-to-cover sells shares in the market, so the employee bears the execution price and gets a small capital gain or loss on the cover shares.

Facts checked November 21, 2026 · Figures for tax year 2026 · 9 sources

Key takeaways

  1. Both net-share settlement and sell-to-cover implement the same withholding: for 2026, a flat 22% federal rate on supplemental wages up to $1 million and a mandatory 37% above that.
  2. IRS Publication 15 allows the optional flat rate to be exactly 22%, with no other percentage, so neither mechanic lets the flat rate rise to an employee's actual bracket.
  3. Under sell-to-cover, the cover shares have a basis equal to the vest-date value, so selling them above or below that price creates a small short-term gain or loss on Form 8949.
  4. Net-share settlement produces no Form 1099-B sale for the withheld shares, because they never leave the company; only any fractional-share cash appears.
  5. A California employee above the 2026 Social Security wage base can face about 35.88% of combined withholding on an RSU vest: 22% federal, 1.45% Medicare, 0.9% Additional Medicare, 10.23% California and 1.3% SDI.

Consider a senior engineer in California whose 1,000 RSUs vest in late 2026 at $185 per share. Gross compensation is $185,000. The engineer’s wages for the year are already above the 2026 Social Security wage base of $184,500 and above the $200,000 Additional Medicare withholding threshold, so the withholding on this vest is 22% federal, 1.45% Medicare, 0.9% Additional Medicare, 10.23% California supplemental and 1.3% California SDI, or 35.88% in total: $66,378.

Under net-share settlement the company keeps about 359 shares and delivers 641. Under sell-to-cover a broker sells roughly 355 to 363 shares in the market, depending on the price it gets, and delivers the rest. Both mechanics meet the same withholding obligation, but they handle fractional shares, fees and execution price differently, and those differences add up across many vests and grants.

How does net-share settlement work?

Net-share settlement works by having the company keep enough vested shares to cover the withholding and pay the tax from its own cash. On the vest date, the company values the vest at the fair market value set by the plan, computes the withholding, converts it into a number of shares, and delivers the remainder.

In the example, $66,378 of withholding at $185 per share equals 358.8 shares. The withheld shares never reach the employee’s account. The company keeps them and remits $66,378 (or the rounded amount) to the IRS, California and the payroll tax accounts.

How are fractional shares handled?

Fractional shares are handled however the plan document says. Common approaches are:

  • Round up. The company withholds 359 whole shares ($66,415), and the extra $37 is treated as additional withholding credited on Form W-2.
  • Round down. The company withholds 358 shares ($66,230), and the $148 shortfall is collected from the employee’s paycheck.
  • Cash for the fraction. The share count to deliver is computed exactly, and any fraction of a share is paid in cash, reported as a small sale.

Each approach moves only a few dollars per vest, but the method affects whether the W-2 withholding matches the computed amount.

How does sell-to-cover work?

Sell-to-cover works by having a broker sell enough vested shares in the market to raise the withholding in cash, which goes to the company, while the remaining shares go to the employee. The number of shares sold depends on the price the broker actually gets.

In the example, $66,378 of withholding needs:

Execution priceShares sold (rounded up)Shares deliveredGain or loss on cover shares
$183363637Loss of $726
$185359641About zero
$187355645Gain of $710

Each delivered share and each cover share has a basis of $185, the vest-date value already taxed as wages. The gain or loss on the cover shares is the difference between the sale price and $185, short-term because the holding period is a few days at most.

What is execution slippage?

Execution slippage is the gap between the vest-date value and the price at which the cover shares sell. On a day when the stock opens lower, the broker sells more shares to raise the same cash and the employee keeps fewer. On a day it opens higher, the employee keeps more. Some brokers execute over a period rather than at a single price, which adds intraday movement. Over many vests, slippage tends to net out, but any single vest can look arbitrary.

How do the two mechanics compare?

The two mechanics produce the same wages, the same basis and the same tax withheld; they differ in who bears the execution price and how the sale is reported.

ElementNet-share settlementSell-to-cover
Shares withheld or soldWhole shares, rounding set by the planWhatever the market sale requires
Price used for the coverPlan’s vest-date valueActual execution price
Who bears execution riskThe companyThe employee
FeesNone for the withheld sharesDepends on the plan administrator
Delivered share countPredictableVariable
Basis of delivered sharesVest-date valueVest-date value
Form 1099-B entryOnly for any fractional cashFor every cover sale

When does one mechanic come out ahead?

Net-share settlement comes out ahead for the employee on days when the stock falls between the valuation point and the sale, because the company absorbs that movement. Sell-to-cover comes out ahead on days the stock rises, and for employees who intend to sell their vested shares anyway, because part of that sale happens automatically.

From the company’s side, net-share settlement uses corporate cash to pay the tax and reduces the shares that end up outstanding, while sell-to-cover keeps the company’s cash untouched and puts the cover shares into the market.

Who chooses the mechanic?

The company usually chooses the mechanic as a plan design decision, applied to all employees. Some plans let employees choose between methods, or choose to pay withholding in cash, through the plan administrator’s portal. The plan documents and the administrator’s settlement election page show which options exist.

Why do both mechanics under-withhold for many employees?

Both mechanics under-withhold for many senior employees because they implement the same flat federal rate. IRS Publication 15 states that under the optional flat-rate method the employer withholds a flat 22%, with no other percentage allowed, on supplemental wages up to $1 million in the year.

For an engineer whose top federal bracket is 32%, 35% or 37%, that leaves a shortfall of 10 to 15 percentage points on every RSU dollar below $1 million. Neither settlement method changes this, because the mechanic only carries out the withholding rate. The gap is paid with the return, through extra withholding on regular pay via Form W-4, or through quarterly estimated payments. For 2026, a taxpayer whose 2025 AGI was above $150,000 meets the prior-year estimated tax safe harbor by paying in 110% of the prior year’s tax.

What happens above $1 million of supplemental wages?

Above $1 million of supplemental wages in a calendar year, withholding at 37% is mandatory regardless of Form W-4. An engineer with $1,200,000 of RSU income in 2026 has $1,000,000 withheld at 22% ($220,000) and $200,000 at 37% ($74,000). For someone in the 37% bracket, withholding above the threshold is accurate and withholding below it is short.

How are fractional shares and cover sales reported?

Fractional-share cash and sell-to-cover sales are reported as sales on Form 1099-B and then on Form 8949, with basis equal to the vest-date value and proceeds equal to the actual sale price. The gain or loss is usually small and short-term.

Consider a vest of 1,247 shares at $185 under the same 35.88% withholding. The withholding is $82,773.37, or 447.42 shares. A plan that withholds exactly that amount delivers 799.58 shares; if it pays cash for the 0.58 share, that small sale appears on Form 1099-B as a separate transaction.

What if Form 1099-B shows the wrong basis?

RSU shares acquired after 2010 are generally covered securities, so the broker should report a basis in box 1e of Form 1099-B. Some brokers still report the basis of RSU cover sales as zero or as unknown, which would make the entire sale price look like gain. The Form 8949 instructions provide an adjustment when the basis shown in box 1e is incorrect: the reported basis is entered, code B goes in column (f), and the correction goes in column (g). The broker’s supplemental statement usually shows the vest-date value to use.

The RSU withholding gap calculator compares withholding under these defaults with tax at a given marginal rate.

Questions people ask next

Why does a sell-to-cover broker statement look so different from net-share settlement?

A sell-to-cover broker statement shows real market sales of the cover shares, which appear on Form 1099-B and must be reported on Form 8949. Under net-share settlement, the withheld shares are kept by the company and never sold by the employee, so no Form 1099-B entry exists for them. Only cash paid for any fractional share shows up as a sale.

Does the broker charge a commission on sell-to-cover sales?

Whether a sell-to-cover sale carries a commission or fee depends on the stock plan administrator and the company's contract with it. Some companies pay the cost, and others pass a per-transaction fee through to the employee, where it reduces the sale proceeds on Form 1099-B. The plan's fee schedule shows which arrangement applies.

What happens if the stock drops between the RSU vest and the sell-to-cover sale?

If the stock drops before the cover shares are sold, more shares must be sold to raise the same withholding, so fewer shares are delivered. The taxable wages stay at the vest-date value, which is also the basis of every share, so the cover sale produces a short-term capital loss equal to the price drop on the shares sold.

Can an employee choose a higher flat withholding rate on RSU income?

Under the optional flat-rate method, IRS Publication 15 sets federal withholding on supplemental wages at exactly 22% for 2026, with no other percentage allowed, and 37% above $1 million. Employees whose bracket is higher usually cover the gap through extra withholding on regular pay via Form W-4 or through quarterly estimated tax payments.

What happens to the shares withheld in net-share settlement?

Shares withheld in net-share settlement are never delivered to the employee. The company keeps them, typically returning them to treasury or to the plan's share reserve, and pays the withholding to the tax authorities from its own cash. Under sell-to-cover, the cover shares are sold in the market and end up held by the buyers.

Sources

  1. IRS Publication 15 (2026), (Circular E), Employer's Tax Guideirs.gov
    Supporting text
    The withholding rate on supplemental wages remains 22% (37% if supplemental wages paid to an employee during the calendar year exceed $1 million) because P.L. 119-21 permanently extended the individual tax rates
  2. IRS Topic no. 560, Additional Medicare taxirs.gov
    Supporting text
    A 0.9% Additional Medicare tax applies to Medicare wages, self-employment income, and railroad retirement (RRTA) compensation that exceed the following threshold amounts based on filing status:
  3. IRS Form 1040-ES (2026), Estimated Tax for Individualsirs.gov
    Supporting text
    If your adjusted gross income (AGI) for 2025 was more than $150,000 ($75,000 if your filing status for 2026 is married filing separately), substitute 110% for 100% in (2b) under General Rule
  4. FTB Tax News October 2026 - 2026 Indexingftb.ca.gov
    Supporting text
    460,927 768,213 39,951.95 + 11.30% of the amount over 460,927 768,213 & OVER 74,675.27 + 12.30% of the amount over 768,213
  5. FTB 2025 Form 540 Booklet, Schedule CA line 7aftb.ca.gov
    Supporting text
    California taxes long and short term capital gains as regular income. No special rate for long term capital gains exists.
  6. FTB 2025 Schedule P (540)ftb.ca.gov
    Supporting text
    24 Tentative Minimum Tax. Multiply line 23 by 7.0% (.07)
  7. California Employer's Guide 2026 (DE 44 Rev. 52)edd.ca.gov
    Supporting text
    Supplemental Wages Percentage Bonuses and stock options 10.23 percent (.1023) Other types (such as overtime pay, commissions, sales awards, severance, and vacation pay) 6.6 percent (.066)
  8. FTB 2025 Instructions for Schedule D (540), California Capital Gain or Loss Adjustmentftb.ca.gov
    Supporting text
    Qualified Small Business Stock – California does not conform to the qualified small business stock deferral and gain exclusion under IRC Sections 1045 and 1202. Enter the entire gain realized in column (e).
  9. IRS Instructions for Form 8949irs.gov
    Supporting text
    the basis shown in box 1e on Form 1099-B or box 1g on Form 1099-DA is incorrect.

Facts checked November 21, 2026 · Tax year 2026

Find a fee-only advisor for your equity

Four questions. You see up to three fee-only advisors listed on Wellspent whose records include equity compensation, right here. Free, no obligation.

  • What happens next: your matches appear on this page straight away. Advisors are not sent your details: you open a record and contact the advisor yourself.
  • What is shared: your email stays with VestedGrant and is not passed to advisors. The advisor directory (Wellspent) receives your state and topic; an AI model ranks the matches from your answers, without your email. Details in the privacy policy.
Back-Weighted 5/15/40/40 RSU Vesting: Why Year 3 Is a Tax Problem A 5/15/40/40 schedule vests 80% of an RSU grant in years three and four, so one year's vest can push a single filer into the 35% or 37% federal bracket. For 2026, employers may withhold a flat 22% on supplemental wages up to $1 million, while the 37% bracket starts at $640,600 of taxable income. In the example on this page, the gap is about $75,900 due at filing. The Complete RSU Guide: Vesting, Taxes, and What to Do at Each Vest RSUs are taxed as ordinary wages on the vest date at the shares' fair market value under IRC Section 83. For 2026, employers usually withhold federal income tax at a flat 22% on supplemental wages up to $1 million and must withhold 37% above that, plus Social Security (6.2% up to $184,500) and Medicare. Employees in the 32% to 37% brackets often owe more in April. NSO Supplemental Withholding: 22% and 37% Under §3402(g) For 2026, federal withholding on an NSO spread is a flat 22% on the first $1 million of supplemental wages in the calendar year and a mandatory 37% on supplemental wages above $1 million, regardless of Form W-4. Employers may instead use the aggregate method below $1 million. For employees in the 32%, 35% or 37% brackets, 22% under-withholds, and the gap is paid through estimated tax, extra W-4 withholding or with the return. Reading Your W-2 When You Have RSU Income: Box 1 vs Box 14 RSU income appears in W-2 Box 1 as part of taxable wages, in Box 5 as Medicare wages, and in Box 3 only up to the Social Security wage base ($176,100 for 2025, $184,500 for 2026). Box 14, renamed Box 14a on 2026 forms, is an informational field where many employers label the RSU portion of Box 1. That label is not added to income again; it helps adjust the 1099-B basis.
Find a fee-only advisor