Forge vs EquityZen vs Clarity (formerly Hiive) vs NPM: Platform Comparison for Sellers
By VestedGrant Editorial · Updated · Tax year 2026 · 7 min read
George Inness, Catskill Mountains, 1870 The main private company secondary venues differ in model. Forge, owned by Charles Schwab since March 2026, offers direct share purchases and single and multicompany funds. EquityZen buys largely through single-company SPVs. Clarity (formerly Hiive) is a direct marketplace where only the seller pays a fee, with a $25,000 minimum. Nasdaq Private Market runs company tender offers. Sellers compare each venue's net price after fees.
Facts checked November 21, 2026 · Figures for tax year 2026 · 7 sources
Key takeaways
- Charles Schwab completed its acquisition of Forge Global in March 2026; Forge offers direct private share purchases, single company funds and multicompany funds.
- Clarity (formerly Hiive) says only the seller pays a fee on a closed transaction, based on transaction size, with a $25,000 minimum.
- Nasdaq Private Market offers tender offers and liquidity programs that companies run, alongside a platform for buying and selling private company stock.
- Clarity says options must be exercised into stock before they can be sold, though some buyers help fund the exercise price.
- A company that approves transfers only through certain programs or venues can block a sale arranged elsewhere, so the company's process comes before platform choice.
Several venues handle much of the secondary trading in private company stock, including Forge, EquityZen, Clarity (formerly Hiive) and Nasdaq Private Market (NPM). Each has a different model and fee approach, and each suits a different kind of seller. A hypothetical holder selling 5,000 shares of a well-known late-stage company faces different choices from a founder selling $30 million of stock in a mid-stage company.
This comparison covers how the venues differ, where each fits, what each publishes about fees and minimums, and the operational points that matter on the sell side. Fee schedules and terms change, so sellers confirm current terms in writing with each venue before listing.
How do the main secondary venues differ?
The main secondary venues differ in whether they match buyers and sellers directly, pool buyers into fund vehicles, or run programs on behalf of companies.
What is Forge?
Forge Global is a private markets platform that Charles Schwab acquired; Schwab completed the acquisition in March 2026. According to the announcement, Forge gives eligible investors direct and indirect access to pre-IPO shares through direct private share purchases, single company funds and multicompany funds. For sellers, that means buyers may be individuals or institutions buying directly, or funds that Forge or others manage.
What is EquityZen?
EquityZen is a private company marketplace whose buyers are often special purpose vehicles (SPVs). EquityZen describes an SPV as a vehicle formed specifically to buy a given private company’s shares from an existing shareholder, with investors interested in that company committing capital to it. For sellers, the buyer is often such a vehicle. EquityZen’s terms are provided to sellers on its platform.
What is Clarity (formerly Hiive)?
Clarity (formerly Hiive) is a marketplace in which buyers and sellers post indications and negotiate directly. Its FAQ for employee shareholders says there is no fee to open an account, post an indication or review pricing data; the seller pays a fee, based on the size of the transaction, only when a sale closes or when a right of first refusal purchase is triggered by an offer found on Clarity; and only the seller pays. Clarity’s minimum transaction amount is $25,000.
What is Nasdaq Private Market?
Nasdaq Private Market offers tender offers and liquidity programs for companies, along with a platform for buying and selling private company stock and private market data. Its tender and liquidity programs are run by the company, which sets the terms and decides who can participate.
How do the venues compare side by side?
The table summarizes the model at each venue and what a seller should confirm. Published or quoted fees and minimums change, so the right column lists what to ask rather than figures that may be out of date.
| Venue | Model | What the venue says publicly | What to confirm before listing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Forge (Schwab) | Direct trades plus single and multicompany funds | Direct and indirect access through direct purchases and funds | Seller fee, minimum size, whether a fund is the buyer |
| EquityZen | Single-company SPVs as buyers | Terms provided on its platform | Seller fee, SPV structure, minimum size |
| Clarity (formerly Hiive) | Direct marketplace | Seller-only fee based on transaction size; $25,000 minimum | Current fee for the transaction size |
| Nasdaq Private Market | Company tender offers and liquidity programs, plus a trading platform | Tender and liquidity programs for companies | Whether the company runs a program and its terms |
Which venue fits which seller?
The right venue depends on the company, the size of the sale and how much time the seller has.
Which venue fits a seller of a well-known late-stage company?
Holders of well-known late-stage stock usually find buyer interest on more than one venue. A direct marketplace shows posted indications and lets the seller negotiate; venues with fund buyers may produce strong bids when a single-company fund has investors to place. Getting indications from more than one venue is the way to see the range.
Which venue fits a seller of a less-traded company?
For mid-stage or less-traded companies, fund vehicles can pool smaller buyers who would not trade individually, which can make a sale possible where a direct marketplace has few buyers. The trade-off may be higher total costs on the buyer side, which shows up in the price.
Which route fits a seller of a very large block?
For very large blocks, a seller may work with a broker-dealer that specializes in secondaries or negotiate directly with a secondary fund or existing investor, in addition to or instead of a platform. Fees and process in those deals are negotiated case by case.
What about founders?
Founder sales draw attention inside the company and among investors. Sales through a company-run program, where the company structures and approves the transaction, are often the simplest. Outside such a program, a negotiated sale to an existing investor or a secondary fund keeps the process private.
What about a seller with time to wait?
A seller with time can get indications from several venues, compare net prices and wait for a competitive bid. The cost is the work of managing several conversations and making sure the same shares are not committed twice.
What operational differences matter?
Several operational differences between venues affect the seller’s experience and net result.
How much pricing information does each venue show?
Venues differ in how much they show. Direct marketplaces typically show posted indications and some recent pricing; fund-based venues may publish indicative prices; company tender programs set one price for everyone. Clarity’s FAQ says it provides pricing and transaction data at no charge to account holders.
How long does each route take to close?
Time to close depends mostly on the company’s transfer review, including its right of first refusal window and approval, and on how quickly a buyer commits and funds. Sales to a newly formed fund can take longer if the fund has to finish raising money. A company tender offer runs on the company’s schedule and must stay open at least twenty business days under SEC rules.
Does the company approve the venue?
Some companies work only with particular venues or programs and decline transfers arranged elsewhere. The company’s equity or legal team can say whether it has an approved process. If the company only approves sales through its own program, a listing on another venue is likely to fail at the company review even if a buyer agrees on price.
Who are the buyers?
Buyer mix varies: single-company funds, multicompany funds, institutions, family offices and accredited individuals. Company tender programs often have a lead investor or a small group of buyers chosen by the company.
How do fees compare across venues?
Fee structures differ by venue, change over time and are sometimes negotiable for large transactions. The only reliable comparison is each venue’s current written terms for the specific transaction.
Clarity’s published approach is the simplest to describe: a seller-only fee based on transaction size, charged only when a sale closes or a right of first refusal purchase is triggered, with no fee if the company blocks the transfer, and a $25,000 minimum. Other venues may charge sellers, buyers or both, and fund-based buyers may pay fund-level fees that affect what they bid. In a company-run tender offer, the company sets any seller fees, and the offer documents state them.
Fees reduce the amount realized on the sale, so they reduce the taxable gain. For a single filer in 2026, long-term gains are taxed at 0%, 15% or 20%, with the 20% rate above $545,500 of taxable income, plus the 3.8% net investment income tax for higher earners. The secondary market fees guide covers the fee layers in detail.
How can a seller get the best net price?
A seller gets the best net price by comparing net proceeds, not headline bids, and by making the transaction easy to close.
Pricing against evidence helps. Recent trades and current indications for the company on more than one venue show where buyers are; a listing priced within that range sells faster, while a higher price may mean waiting.
Prompt responses help. Buyers move on when sellers are slow to answer.
Clean documents help. Proof of ownership, the relevant share certificates or cap table records, and the company’s transfer forms shorten the company review.
Keeping deadlines private helps. Buyers who know a seller needs cash by a date can bid lower.
Fee negotiation helps on larger trades. On a hypothetical $500,000 sale, each percentage point of fees is $5,000; on $5 million it is $50,000.
Before listing, a seller can request indicative pricing from more than one venue for the specific company and share count, check whether the company has an approved venue or an upcoming tender, and compare the net proceeds after fees. The secondary market sales guide covers the steps from listing to closing.
Questions people ask next
Can private company shares be listed on several secondary platforms at once?
Listing on several secondary platforms at once is often possible, because many platforms do not require exclusivity, but each listing has to be managed so that the same shares are not sold twice. Once a purchase agreement is signed on one platform, listings elsewhere need to come down. The company sees each transfer notice, so multiple simultaneous notices for the same shares can complicate its review.
Can I sell on a platform while my company's tender offer is open?
Companies often pause individual transfers while a tender offer is open, and a company can decline to approve a platform sale during that window under its transfer provisions. The tender offer documents and the company's equity team say whether individual sales are paused. If they are, the tender itself is usually the available route to sell during that period.
Do sellers on secondary platforms need to be accredited investors?
Sellers generally do not need to be accredited investors; the accreditation requirements apply to buyers. Clarity (formerly Hiive) says that someone who does not qualify as an accredited investor can still sign up as a seller only. Each platform sets its own onboarding rules, and the company's transfer provisions may separately restrict who can buy.
How do secondary platforms handle the company's right of first refusal?
Secondary platforms generally prepare the transfer notice and documents for the company, and the right of first refusal then runs on the company's own contractual window. If the company exercises, the company or its designee buys on the agreed terms; if it blocks the transfer, the sale does not close. Clarity says it charges no fee when the company blocks a transfer.
Can unvested RSUs or unexercised options be sold on a secondary platform?
Secondary platforms generally trade shares of stock, not unvested RSUs or unexercised options. Clarity says options must be exercised into stock before the shares can be sold, though some buyers help fund the exercise price and some companies allow a cashless exercise at closing. RSUs that have not settled into shares cannot be transferred under most grant agreements.
Sources
- Rev. Proc. 2025-32irs.gov
Supporting text
Heads of Household $66,200 $579,600 All Other Individuals $49,450 $545,500
- IRS Topic no. 559, Net investment income taxirs.gov
Supporting text
A 3.8 percent net investment income tax (NIIT) applies to individuals, estates, and trusts that have net investment income above applicable threshold amounts.
- EquityZen, Understanding Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs) (May 19, 2025)blog.equityzen.com
Supporting text
An SPV is formed specifically to purchase the shares of a given private company from the existing shareholder. This is often done by platforms like EquityZen that specialize in secondary market transactions.
- Charles Schwab Completes Acquisition of Forge Global (Business Wire via Nasdaq, March 2, 2026)nasdaq.com
Supporting text
The Charles Schwab Corporation (Schwab) today announced that it has completed its acquisition of Forge Global Holdings, Inc. (Forge).
- Clarity, homepageclarity.com
Supporting text
A letter from our founder Hiive is now Clarity
- Clarity, frequently asked questions for employee shareholdersclarity.com
Supporting text
On Clarity, only the seller pays a fee in the event of a closed transaction.
- Nasdaq Private Market, productsnasdaqprivatemarket.com
Supporting text
Tender offers and liquidity programs Investment Platform Buy and sell private company stock
Facts checked November 21, 2026 · Tax year 2026
Find a fee-only advisor for your equity
Four questions. You see up to three fee-only advisors listed on Wellspent whose records include equity compensation, right here. Free, no obligation.
- What happens next: your matches appear on this page straight away. Advisors are not sent your details: you open a record and contact the advisor yourself.
- What is shared: your email stays with VestedGrant and is not passed to advisors. The advisor directory (Wellspent) receives your state and topic; an AI model ranks the matches from your answers, without your email. Details in the privacy policy.
Finding fee-only advisors for your answers…
Three advisors picked for your situation
Each is a fee-only advisor listed on Wellspent whose record includes equity compensation. Open a record to see how they work and to contact them directly. No referral fees either way.
No advisor matched those details yet
Try again with "Other / outside the US" as the state, or browse equity-compensation advisors on Wellspent.