Variable prepaid forward
Also called variable prepaid forward, VPF, prepaid variable forward
A variable prepaid forward is a contract in which a shareholder takes cash now and later delivers a number of shares that varies between a floor and a cap price. Because the number of shares is not fixed, it is designed to avoid being a forward contract for a 'substantially fixed amount of property,' which Section 1259 treats as a constructive sale taxed immediately.
Facts checked November 21, 2026
A variable prepaid forward is a tailored contract between a shareholder and a bank or dealer. The shareholder agrees to deliver shares at a future date, typically a few years out, pledges the shares as collateral, and receives a cash payment up front that is a discount to the current value of the shares. At settlement, the number of shares delivered depends on the share price then: all of the pledged shares if the price is at or below a floor, fewer shares as the price rises between the floor and a cap, and a number that leaves the shareholder only the gain up to the cap if the price ends above it. The shareholder gives up the downside below the floor and the upside above the cap, keeps the range in between, and receives cash now. Because the number of shares is not substantially fixed, the contract is structured to avoid being a constructive sale under Section 1259, so capital gain is generally deferred until settlement.
Example (hypothetical): consider an executive of a public company who holds $30 million of stock with a very low basis. A dealer pays her about $23 million today against delivery of up to all of the shares in three years, with a floor at the current price and a cap at 135% of it. If the stock falls, she delivers all the shares and keeps the $23 million. If it rises 80%, she delivers enough shares to leave her the gain up to the 135% cap, and the dealer keeps the rest of the rise. No sale is recognized when the contract is signed, because she has not yet disposed of the shares.
Common mistake: designing the contract so tightly that it removes nearly all risk and reward, for example with a cap barely above the floor. A position like that can look like a forward contract to deliver a substantially fixed amount of property, which Section 1259 treats as a constructive sale, making the gain taxable at once.
Variable prepaid forwards matter for executives and early holders with concentrated positions in the millions of dollars, and in windows when other hedges or sales are restricted.
Sources
- 26 U.S.C. § 1259 (Constructive sales treatment for appreciated financial positions)uscode.house.gov
Supporting text
enters into a futures or forward contract to deliver the same or substantially identical property
Facts checked November 21, 2026