VestedGrant
Find an advisor

Anchoring to a Previous Stock-Price High: The Refusal to Sell Below It

By VestedGrant Editorial · Updated · Tax year 2026 · 7 min read

Claude Monet, Stacks of Wheat (End of Summer), 1890–91

Anchoring is the tendency to judge a number by adjusting from a starting value, even an irrelevant one, and adjusting too little. Tversky and Kahneman showed in 1974 that a random wheel-of-fortune number shifted people's estimates. With employer stock, a past high or the vest-date price becomes the anchor, and holders refuse to sell below it even though the anchor says nothing about future value. Pre-set selling rules remove the anchor from the decision.

Facts checked November 21, 2026 · Figures for tax year 2026 · 9 sources

Key takeaways

  1. In Tversky and Kahneman's 1974 anchoring study, groups that saw 10 or 65 on a wheel of fortune gave median estimates of 25 and 45 for the same question.
  2. For RSUs, the value included in income at vesting becomes the cost basis, which makes it a tax reference point, not an estimate of what the shares are worth now.
  3. Selling below the vest-date basis creates a capital loss that offsets capital gains, plus up to $3,000 a year of ordinary income, with the rest carried forward.
  4. A Rule 10b5-1 plan sets sales in advance; directors and officers wait at least 90 days before the first trade and other employees 30 days.
  5. Kahneman's Nobel lecture reports that most people refuse an even-odds bet unless the possible win is at least twice the possible loss, which is why a price below the anchor feels so painful.

In a 1974 paper, Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman showed that arbitrary starting numbers pull people’s estimates toward them. Subjects watched a wheel of fortune produce a number between 0 and 100, then estimated quantities such as the percentage of African countries in the United Nations. Groups that saw 10 gave a median estimate of 25; groups that saw 65 gave a median estimate of 45. Paying for accuracy did not remove the effect.

Applied to equity compensation, anchoring produces a specific pattern. Consider a hypothetical employee who watches the company’s stock reach $220 in January. By October it has fallen to $110. Two years later it trades at $170. The employee cannot bring themselves to sell, because $170 is “still below the high.” The unspoken assumption is that the stock is underpriced until it returns to $220.

That assumption does not hold up. The $220 price was set in a particular market, with particular interest rates and particular expectations about growth. It contains no information about what the business is worth now. Yet it shapes every later sell decision. This article describes why the anchor is so strong for vested stock and which structures take it out of the decision.

Why does a previous high become such a strong anchor?

A previous high sticks because it is vivid, personal and easy to recall, and because people evaluate outcomes against reference points rather than in absolute terms. Four features make the high a particularly strong reference point for employees:

  1. Salience. Employees usually notice the high when it happens, talk about it and remember it. It carries emotional weight that later, ordinary prices do not.
  2. Aspiration. The high marks the largest value the employee’s equity ever reached. Selling below it feels like accepting a smaller outcome than the one already “seen.”
  3. Narrative. Highs often coincide with good news, such as a strong quarter or a product launch. The story fades from memory faster than the number.
  4. Insufficient adjustment. Asked what price they would sell at, people start from the remembered number and adjust downward too little, the pattern Tversky and Kahneman described.

The 2017 Nobel committee’s summary of Richard Thaler’s work notes that one common reference point is the price for which an item was bought. For employees, the purchase price is often replaced by the vest price or the high, but the effect is the same: the sell threshold sits above the current market and has no connection to the value of the business today.

Why is the current price a better reference than the old high?

The current price summarizes what buyers and sellers believe the stock is worth with all the information available today. The old high summarized what buyers and sellers believed in a different market, with different interest rates, competitors and growth assumptions. Neither number is “correct” in an absolute sense, but the current price includes everything learned since the high, and the old high includes none of it.

A holder deciding whether to sell has two relevant questions:

  • What can the shares be sold for now? The answer is the current price.
  • What might holding produce? The answer is the range of possible future prices, which depends on the company’s prospects from here.

The previous high answers neither question. Anchoring inserts it anyway, as if the market owes the holder a return to that level. The holder then waits for the market to come back to the anchor, rather than recognizing that the anchor has no claim to being the right price.

What does anchoring cost in a long drawdown?

Anchoring costs the most when a stock falls hard and stays down. Consider three hypothetical companies whose stocks each fell more than 75% from their peaks during a sector sell-off:

  • Company A recovered to its old high within about two years.
  • Company B recovered part of the way and stalled well below the peak.
  • Company C never recovered and kept trading near its low for years.

An employee at any of the three, anchored on the peak, waited for the stock to “come back.” Employees at Company A were rewarded. Employees at Company C were not. The anchor did not know which company would recover, and neither did the employees. Holding because of the anchor was a bet, not a forecast; a diversified portfolio did not depend on which company was which.

Take a hypothetical Company C employee with $1 million of stock at the peak who holds through a 90% fall that never reverses. The position ends at $100,000. If the same $1 million had been in a diversified portfolio earning an assumed 7% a year for four years, it would have grown to about $1.31 million. The cost of holding the anchored position in this illustration is about $1.21 million.

Why is the vest-date price a misleading anchor?

For RSU holders, the vest-date price is a natural anchor because it is the tax basis. IRS Publication 551 states that when property is received for services, its fair market value is included in income and that amount becomes the basis. An employee who vested at $180 may think, “I was taxed at $180, so selling below $180 is a loss.”

The vest-date price is a reference point for computing gain or loss, not a forecast and not a statement of fair value. Selling at $160 after vesting at $180 produces a $20 per share capital loss. That loss offsets capital gains in the same year; any net loss beyond that offsets up to $3,000 of ordinary income per year, and the remainder carries forward to later years under IRC Section 1212.

Many employees stack anchors. Consider a hypothetical employee whose options were granted at $15, whose stock peaked at $220, whose latest RSUs vested at $180 and whose stock now trades at $140. The employee has three reference points and refuses to sell below any of them, so the effective sell threshold becomes $220, a price the stock may never see again.

A holder who sells at a loss and wants to keep similar exposure should note the wash-sale rule: buying the same stock within 30 days before or after the sale disallows the loss for that year.

What helps people make decisions without the anchor?

Approaches that change how the question is asked can reduce the anchor’s pull. Three are commonly used in planning conversations:

  1. Arguing the other side. Before deciding, the holder writes out the strongest case that the stock is worth much less than the anchor, for example why it might be worth $100 rather than $220. Writing the opposing case makes the anchor easier to see as one possible view.
  2. Comparing with current peers. If the stock is at $170 and a similar company with similar growth and margins trades at a similar multiple, the peer comparison is a more relevant reference than the old high.
  3. Removing the anchor from view. Not checking historical charts before deciding, and framing the choice only in terms of today’s price and today’s portfolio, keeps the old number out of the room.

These approaches help, but anchoring operates largely below conscious reflection. Tversky and Kahneman found that even paying people for accuracy did not remove the effect, which is why structural approaches tend to be more reliable than willpower.

Which structures take the anchor out of the decision?

Structural approaches work because they make the sale decision before any price is known, so the anchor never gets a vote:

  1. Rule 10b5-1 trading plans. A plan sets the amount, price and dates of sales in advance. Directors and officers must wait at least 90 days after adopting the plan (and no more than 120 days in the longer case) before the first trade; other employees wait 30 days. After that, sales happen whether or not the current price feels acceptable.
  2. Exchange funds. Contributing concentrated stock to an exchange fund swaps it, generally without a taxable sale, for an interest in a diversified pool at today’s value. Any anchor then attaches to a diversified holding.
  3. Percentage-based selling. A rule such as “sell 10% of the position every quarter regardless of price” removes price from each decision entirely.

Each structure has its own costs and conditions, covered in separate articles in this series. What they share is that the decision is made once, in advance, instead of being reopened at every price.

What does a promise to sell “when it gets back” signal?

The sentence “I’ll sell when it gets back to $220” is anchoring said out loud. It names a past price as the condition for a future decision.

A few questions can test whether the anchor is doing the work:

  • What happens to the plan if the stock never returns to $220?
  • What if it takes seven years to get there?
  • Looking back from seven years in the future, which choice made today would seem better?

These questions rarely change a decision on the spot. They do make the anchor visible, which tends to make a pre-committed selling rule easier to adopt later. For holders who decide to keep some shares, sizing the retained position from their own view of the company, rather than from the gap between today’s price and the old high, keeps the anchor out of that decision as well.

Questions people ask next

Is anchoring the same thing as loss aversion?

Anchoring and loss aversion are related but distinct. Anchoring sets the reference point, such as a past high or the vest price. Loss aversion makes any outcome below that reference point feel worse than an equal gain feels good; Kahneman's Nobel lecture reports that most people turn down an even-odds bet unless the win is at least twice the loss. Together they produce the habit of holding until the stock gets back to even.

Does anchoring affect stocks that are above their previous high?

Anchoring can work in the other direction as well. A holder whose stock has moved well above an old high may treat the old price as a sign that the stock is now expensive and sell for that reason alone. The old price is just as uninformative in that case. In both directions, the decision rests on a past number instead of the current price and the holder's own portfolio needs.

Can a financial advisor help remove the anchor?

An advisor can help by restating the decision in current terms: what the position is worth today, what share of net worth it represents, and what a severe fall would do to the plan. An advisor who simply agrees to wait for the old high reinforces the anchor instead. Asking an advisor to describe the sale decision without mentioning past prices is one way to test which approach is being used.

Does selling on a fixed schedule get around anchoring?

A fixed schedule sells a set number of shares or a set percentage on set dates whatever the price, so no individual sale depends on whether the stock is above or below a remembered high. Rule 10b5-1 plans formalize this for insiders, with a cooling-off period of at least 90 days for directors and officers and 30 days for other employees before the first trade.

Is selling part of the position and holding the rest a reasonable middle path?

Selling part and holding part captures some diversification while keeping some exposure to a recovery. The anchor tends to return when choosing the size of the retained piece, so planners often size it from the holder's own view of the stock and from what share of net worth could be lost without harming the plan, not from the distance between today's price and the old high.

Sources

  1. IRS Topic no. 409, Capital gains and lossesirs.gov
    Supporting text
    the amount of the excess loss that you can claim to lower your income is the lesser of $3,000 ($1,500 if married filing separately)
  2. 17 CFR 240.10b5-1 (eCFR)ecfr.gov
    Supporting text
    no purchases or sales occur until the expiration of a cooling-off period that is 30 days after the adoption of the contract, instruction or plan;
  3. Tversky and Kahneman, Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases, Science (1974)csc2.ncsu.edu
    Supporting text
    these arbitrary numbers had a marked effect on estimates. For example, the median estimates of the percentage of African countries in the United
  4. Daniel Kahneman, Maps of Bounded Rationality, Nobel Prize lecture (2002)nobelprize.org
    Supporting text
    most people will reject a gamble with even chances to win and lose, unless the possible win is at least twice the size of the possible loss
  5. Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2017, popular informationnobelprize.org
    Supporting text
    One reference point could be the price for which we bought an item, or the lowest price we find when searching on the internet
  6. IRS Publication 551, Basis of Assetsirs.gov
    Supporting text
    If you receive property for services, include the property’s FMV in income. The amount you include in income becomes your basis.
  7. 26 U.S.C. § 1212 (Capital loss carrybacks and carryovers)uscode.house.gov
    Supporting text
    the excess of the net long-term capital loss over the net short-term capital gain for such year shall be a long-term capital loss in the succeeding taxable year
  8. 26 U.S.C. § 1091 (Loss from wash sales of stock or securities)uscode.house.gov
    Supporting text
    within a period beginning 30 days before the date of such sale or disposition and ending 30 days after such date, the taxpayer has acquired
  9. 26 U.S.C. § 721 (Nonrecognition of gain or loss on contribution)uscode.house.gov
    Supporting text
    No gain or loss shall be recognized to a partnership or to any of its partners in the case of a contribution of property to the partnership in exchange for an interest in the partnership.

Facts checked November 21, 2026 · Tax year 2026

Find a fee-only advisor for your equity

Four questions. You see up to three fee-only advisors listed on Wellspent whose records include equity compensation, right here. Free, no obligation.

  • What happens next: your matches appear on this page straight away. Advisors are not sent your details: you open a record and contact the advisor yourself.
  • What is shared: your email stays with VestedGrant and is not passed to advisors. The advisor directory (Wellspent) receives your state and topic; an AI model ranks the matches from your answers, without your email. Details in the privacy policy.
The Endowment Effect: Why You Can't Sell Your Vested Stock The endowment effect, named by Richard Thaler in 1980, is the tendency to value something more because one owns it. In experiments by Kahneman, Knetsch and Thaler, owners asked about twice as much to sell a coffee mug as buyers would pay. With vested stock, the effect shows up as refusing to sell shares one would never buy at today's price. Pre-set selling rules, such as Rule 10b5-1 plans, reduce its pull. Loss Aversion and Equity Concentration: The Hold-to-Breakeven Trap Loss aversion is the tendency to feel losses more strongly than equal gains; Kahneman's Nobel lecture reports that most people refuse an even-odds bet unless the possible win is at least twice the possible loss. For RSU holders it produces the hold-to-breakeven trap: refusing to sell below the vest price or a past high. Yet a realized loss offsets capital gains and up to $3,000 a year of ordinary income, with the rest carried forward. Mental Accounting at a Liquidity Event: Why 'Found Money' Gets Spent Worse Mental accounting, a theory developed by Richard Thaler, describes how people sort money into separate mental accounts by source or purpose, even though dollars are interchangeable. Proceeds from an IPO, tender offer or acquisition often land in a windfall account and get spent more freely than salary. For 2026, supplemental withholding of 22% on the first $1 million and 37% above that can also leave a large tax bill at filing time. The 'It's Not Gain Until I Sell' Fallacy An unrealized gain is real wealth whose tax is deferred, not wealth that does not exist yet. Federal law taxes the gain only when the stock is sold, and for 2026 a long-term gain costs a high earner up to 23.8% (20% plus the 3.8% net investment income tax). The holding decision is therefore a trade between that tax cost and the risk of keeping one stock.
Find a fee-only advisor