Mental Accounting at a Liquidity Event: Why 'Found Money' Gets Spent Worse
By VestedGrant Editorial · Updated · Tax year 2026 · 7 min read
Sanford Robinson Gifford, Cows in a Pond at Sunset, 1860 Mental accounting, a theory developed by Richard Thaler, describes how people sort money into separate mental accounts by source or purpose, even though dollars are interchangeable. Proceeds from an IPO, tender offer or acquisition often land in a windfall account and get spent more freely than salary. For 2026, supplemental withholding of 22% on the first $1 million and 37% above that can also leave a large tax bill at filing time.
Facts checked November 21, 2026 · Figures for tax year 2026 · 12 sources
Key takeaways
- The 2017 Nobel committee describes mental accounting as people creating separate accounts in their minds and making decisions by their effect on each account rather than on total wealth.
- Thaler's house money effect describes people taking more risk with money they recently gained, which fits how windfall proceeds are often treated.
- For 2026, federal supplemental withholding is an optional 22% on the first $1 million of supplemental wages and a mandatory 37% above $1 million, and California withholds 10.23% on stock compensation.
- A hypothetical $3 million RSU payout to a California resident would have about $1.27 million withheld but could owe about $1.51 million in income tax, leaving roughly $242,000 due at filing.
- Gifts of up to $19,000 per recipient in 2026 fall under the annual exclusion; larger gifts use part of the $15 million lifetime basic exclusion.
On this page (show sections)
- What are the common windfall labels?
- Why does windfall money feel different from salary?
- What structure can protect most of the proceeds?
- What can windfall spending cost over five years?
- Why does withholding often fall short of the actual tax?
- How do couples end up with conflicting mental accounts?
- Why does the windfall label fade over time?
- Questions people ask next
- Sources
Richard Thaler’s theory of mental accounting, cited when he received the 2017 Nobel Prize in economics, describes how people sort money into separate accounts in their minds and judge each decision by its effect on one account rather than on total wealth. The committee’s summary also describes a “house money effect”: people who have recently gained money tend to take bigger risks with it. The underlying dollars are interchangeable, but the labels are not.
Liquidity events, such as IPO lockup expirations, tender offers and acquisition payouts, produce the strongest version of this labeling. The money arrives in a lump, separate from monthly pay, often after years of waiting. Employees tend to file it as “the windfall,” distinct from “real money,” and the label makes spending feel acceptable that would never be acceptable from salary.
This article describes common mental-accounting patterns around liquidity events, what they can cost, and structures that limit the damage.
What are the common windfall labels?
Planners who work with employees after liquidity events often describe a handful of recurring labels. Each is illustrated here with hypothetical figures:
- “The house fund.” Proceeds are earmarked for a home, and the budget grows to match the windfall rather than the household’s income. A $2 million cash purchase by a household earning $500,000 a year is a home at four times income, well beyond the plan before the event.
- “The family fund.” Part of the money is set aside for relatives: paying off a parent’s mortgage, buying a car for a sibling, funding a relative’s business. Generous intentions can exceed what the plan supports. For 2026, gifts above $19,000 per recipient use part of the $15 million lifetime exclusion and require a gift tax return, even when no tax is due.
- “Retirement.” The employee decides the proceeds mean work is optional. A $5 million lump sum at age 38 supporting $300,000 of annual spending is a 6% draw on the starting balance, before taxes, for a horizon that may exceed 50 years.
- “Independence money.” Proceeds are labeled as freedom from the current employer, which can prompt a departure without a clear next step.
- “The angel fund.” Proceeds are earmarked for startup investments, often spread across many small checks. Early-stage investments are illiquid for years, and results are highly uneven.
Each label permits spending the employee would not accept from a regular budget. A household earning $500,000 a year would not buy a $2 million house from salary; it would buy what income and savings support. The liquidity event removes the constraint, and the label directs the excess.
Why does windfall money feel different from salary?
In purely economic terms, a dollar from an IPO is the same as a dollar from salary. Both land in the same bank account, and both can be spent or invested in the same ways. The tax character differs, since RSU income is taxed as wages and post-vest appreciation as capital gain, but once taxed, the money is interchangeable.
Mental accounting breaks that interchangeability. The Nobel committee’s scientific background describes each mental account as having its own budget and its own reference point, which limits how freely money moves between accounts. An employee might keep several accounts in mind:
- Salary, spent on the regular budget.
- Retirement savings, treated as untouchable.
- An emergency fund, also untouchable.
- The windfall, spendable on whatever it was labeled for.
The windfall account gets spent at a pace salary-based spending would never allow. Feeling differently about a lump sum is natural; it arrives differently and carries different emotional weight. The financial error is letting that feeling set the spending rate.
What structure can protect most of the proceeds?
One approach planners use is a fixed split immediately after the event: move a large majority of the after-tax proceeds, for example 80%, into a separately titled investment account that is not to be spent for a set period, such as 12 months, and treat the remaining 20% as the windfall budget for labeled spending.
For a hypothetical $5 million after-tax event, that means $4 million invested and $1 million available for a house upgrade, family gifts, startup investments or travel. The cap enforces discipline on the labels without pretending the windfall does not exist.
Practical details that make the split stick:
- Open the long-term account at a different firm from the one holding the stock plan account, so moving money back takes deliberate effort.
- Move the invested share within days of the event rather than waiting for a perfect investment decision.
- Give the account a plain name, such as “Long-Term Portfolio,” rather than anything that evokes the windfall.
- Set a rule that any withdrawal requires a waiting period, such as 48 hours, and a written reason.
The friction is deliberate. Research on defaults shows how strongly the starting arrangement shapes behavior: the 2017 Nobel background cites Madrian and Shea’s finding that automatic enrollment raised 401(k) participation from 49% to 86%.
What can windfall spending cost over five years?
Two hypothetical employees each receive $5 million after tax. The returns below are assumptions for illustration, not forecasts: diversified investments grow 8% a year, the house appreciates 20% over five years, and startup investments end up worth one-third of what was invested.
Employee A follows the labels:
| Use | Amount | Value after five years |
|---|---|---|
| House upgrade | $1.5M | $1.8M |
| Family gifts | $0.5M | $0 (spent) |
| Startup investments | $1.5M | $0.5M |
| Diversified investments | $1.5M | about $2.2M |
| Total | $5.0M | about $4.5M |
Employee B uses an 80/20 split:
| Use | Amount | Value after five years |
|---|---|---|
| House upgrade | $0.5M | $0.6M |
| Family gifts | $0.2M | $0 (spent) |
| Startup investments | $0.3M | $0.1M |
| Diversified investments | $4.0M | about $5.88M |
| Total | $5.0M | about $6.58M |
Under these assumptions, the gap after five years is about $2.1 million, driven almost entirely by how the windfall was divided at the start. Employee A also ends with more of the remaining wealth in an illiquid house and hard-to-sell startup stakes.
Why does withholding often fall short of the actual tax?
A common mental-accounting error treats the tax as “already paid” because withholding appeared on the pay statement, so everything left looks spendable. For large RSU payouts, withholding often falls short.
For 2026, employers may withhold federal income tax on supplemental wages, such as RSU income, at a flat 22% up to $1 million in the year, and must withhold 37% on supplemental wages above $1 million. California withholds 10.23% on bonuses and stock compensation for 2026. As a hypothetical example, a $3 million RSU payout to a California resident would have federal withholding of $960,000 ($1 million at 22% plus $2 million at 37%) and California withholding of $306,900, a total of about $1.27 million. The employee sees about $1.73 million net and books it as the windfall.
If the employee’s other income already fills the lower brackets, the payout is taxed at the top federal rate of 37% for 2026 plus California’s top rate, 13.3% for 2026, about 50.3% in total, or roughly $1.51 million. That leaves about $242,000 due at filing, before payroll taxes and any other adjustments.
An employee who has already spent against the larger figure may need to sell assets, possibly at a loss, or borrow to pay the bill. Setting aside the estimated shortfall at the time of the payout avoids that. Estimated tax payments can also avoid underpayment penalties: for 2026, taxpayers whose 2025 AGI exceeded $150,000 generally meet the safe harbor by paying in 110% of their 2025 tax.
How do couples end up with conflicting mental accounts?
Partners often hold different mental accounts for the same money. One partner sees the windfall as “our security.” The other sees it as “the chance to finally start my company.” Each label lives in a separate head and is never negotiated. Six months later, one partner has bought a vacation home and the other has put $400,000 into a new venture, and the household holds far more illiquid exposure than either intended.
A practical step is an explicit conversation before the event. Each partner writes down what they want to do with the proceeds, the lists are compared and reconciled, and the plan is revisited at 6, 12 and 24 months. If one partner wants to invest $500,000 in startups and the other wants to work less, those are different strategies with different cash needs, and both need to fit the same budget.
Writing the shared plan down also gives each partner a fixed reference to check new ideas against, which limits the drift that comes from many separate, unspoken accounts.
Why does the windfall label fade over time?
Mental accounts shift with time. Immediately after the event, the windfall feels separate and untouchable. Six months later, it may have merged into the everyday bank balance, and spending speeds up.
The separately titled account counters that drift. The friction of moving money out stays the same even as the emotional label fades. Many families report that after a year or so they stop thinking about the invested account at all, which is the goal: the money is doing its long-term job without being reconsidered every month.
A scheduled review keeps the structure honest without reopening it constantly. Many families revisit the split once a year, comparing actual spending from the windfall budget with the plan, checking that taxes owed on the event were paid, and deciding whether any part of the invested account should be released for a specific, agreed purpose. The annual review replaces dozens of separate, emotional decisions with one deliberate one.
Questions people ask next
Is mental accounting always harmful?
No. The Nobel committee's summary of Thaler's work notes that mental accounts can help people plan their finances and protect long-term savings. A firm mental label such as "retirement money, do not touch" keeps 401(k) balances from being spent. The problem at a liquidity event is narrower: a windfall label that makes spending at an unsustainable rate feel acceptable.
How much of a windfall is reasonable to spend?
No rule fixes the share. Some planners use a budget of 10% to 20% of after-tax proceeds for discretionary windfall spending, with the rest invested for long-term needs, while others start from a sustainable withdrawal rate on the whole portfolio. The right figure depends on total wealth, age, income, family obligations and how much of the proceeds is needed for taxes still to come.
Should the size of a liquidity event be kept private?
Many advisers suggest keeping the specific amount private, at least at first. Public knowledge tends to bring requests from relatives, friends and acquaintances, and each request becomes another labeled account competing for the money. Deciding on a giving budget in advance, including any gifts above the $19,000 annual exclusion for 2026 that would require a gift tax return, makes those conversations easier.
Is one large splurge after a liquidity event a problem?
A single, defined splurge, such as a trip or a long-wanted purchase, set within a budget decided in advance, is usually manageable. The larger risk is a series of upgrades that become the new baseline: a larger house, higher running costs, new recurring commitments. Those raise annual spending permanently, which reduces what the proceeds can support over the decades that follow.
How quickly can lifestyle creep use up a windfall?
Faster than it looks. As a hypothetical example, a permanent $200,000 a year increase in spending drawn from a $5 million windfall uses 4% of the starting balance every year before any investment return, inflation or taxes. If the portfolio earns less than the withdrawals plus inflation, the balance shrinks each year, and the shortfall compounds over a long horizon.
Sources
- IRS Publication 15 (2026), (Circular E), Employer's Tax Guideirs.gov
Supporting text
The withholding rate on supplemental wages remains 22% (37% if supplemental wages paid to an employee during the calendar year exceed $1 million) because P.L. 119-21 permanently extended the individual tax rates
- Rev. Proc. 2025-32irs.gov
Supporting text
Over $640,600 $192,979.25 plus 37% of the excess over $640,600
- IRS Form 1040-ES (2026), Estimated Tax for Individualsirs.gov
Supporting text
If your adjusted gross income (AGI) for 2025 was more than $150,000 ($75,000 if your filing status for 2026 is married filing separately), substitute 110% for 100% in (2b) under General Rule
- FTB Tax News October 2026 - 2026 Indexingftb.ca.gov
Supporting text
460,927 768,213 39,951.95 + 11.30% of the amount over 460,927 768,213 & OVER 74,675.27 + 12.30% of the amount over 768,213
- FTB 2025 Form 540 Booklet, Schedule CA line 7aftb.ca.gov
Supporting text
California taxes long and short term capital gains as regular income. No special rate for long term capital gains exists.
- FTB 2025 Schedule P (540)ftb.ca.gov
Supporting text
24 Tentative Minimum Tax. Multiply line 23 by 7.0% (.07)
- California Employer's Guide 2026 (DE 44 Rev. 52)edd.ca.gov
Supporting text
Supplemental Wages Percentage Bonuses and stock options 10.23 percent (.1023) Other types (such as overtime pay, commissions, sales awards, severance, and vacation pay) 6.6 percent (.066)
- FTB 2025 Instructions for Schedule D (540), California Capital Gain or Loss Adjustmentftb.ca.gov
Supporting text
Qualified Small Business Stock – California does not conform to the qualified small business stock deferral and gain exclusion under IRC Sections 1045 and 1202. Enter the entire gain realized in column (e).
Show 4 more sources
- FTB 2026 Instructions for Form 540-ES, Behavioral Health Services Taxftb.ca.gov
Supporting text
Less: $(1,000,000) Subtotal Tax rate – 1%: × .01 Behavioral Health Services Tax
- Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2017, popular informationnobelprize.org
Supporting text
We tend to simplify such decisions by creating separate accounts in our minds, making individual decisions on the basis of their effect on each of these accounts rather than on our total assets.
- Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, Scientific Background on the 2017 Economics Prize (Richard Thaler)nobelprize.org
Supporting text
Each account has its own budget and its own separate reference point, which results in limited fungibility between the accounts.
- 26 U.S.C. § 6019 (Gift tax returns)uscode.house.gov
Supporting text
Any individual who in any calendar year makes any transfer by gift other than (1) a transfer which under subsection (b) or (e) of section 2503 is not to be included in the total amount of gifts for such year
Facts checked November 21, 2026 · Tax year 2026
Find a fee-only advisor for your equity
Four questions. You see up to three fee-only advisors listed on Wellspent whose records include equity compensation, right here. Free, no obligation.
- What happens next: your matches appear on this page straight away. Advisors are not sent your details: you open a record and contact the advisor yourself.
- What is shared: your email stays with VestedGrant and is not passed to advisors. The advisor directory (Wellspent) receives your state and topic; an AI model ranks the matches from your answers, without your email. Details in the privacy policy.
Finding fee-only advisors for your answers…
Three advisors picked for your situation
Each is a fee-only advisor listed on Wellspent whose record includes equity compensation. Open a record to see how they work and to contact them directly. No referral fees either way.
No advisor matched those details yet
Try again with "Other / outside the US" as the state, or browse equity-compensation advisors on Wellspent.